19 Best Insurance Services in Staten Island, NY

Margaret Lacey Berman I usually pay all of my insurance invoices directly on the Nationwide website. This year we were lucky enough to pay off our mortgage so I needed to pay our home insurance directly. The website had not been updated and would not permit me to pay the insurance invoice. So whenever I have an issue I call Frank Manos he always can help me with my insurance challenges. In a matter of minutes Frank updated the situation he was able to accept my payment (I did not want it to be late) and made sure I was set up for next years payment. Frank Manos has always been an outstanding insurance agent and it is a pleasure working with him.

Gloria Alverio Very sarcastic, no patience, unprofessional staff who tell you they will call you back and dont. I wouldnt recommend them for insurance coverage to anyone.

Indu sanora This place is horrible. I was with Riccardo and he did my paperwork and got a cheap plan 307$ for months and asking for down payment 1800$ and I pay by credit cards after one month I received a letter from progressive my insurance was get up price and need to pay 7740$ after few days. I was in the hospital for my heart surgery and came back to see this letter. I went to the roth agent and I spoke to same guy Riccardo he said I need some paperwork and i give him all of it but he didn’t do anything and he left my paperwork front his table and he went vacation. Then i go talk with Frank the owner and he was telling me call tomorrow morning 9 am then he said he will fix today before 5 pm but what happened? Nothing any change my insurance cancelled after 12 am I lose my insurance and just 2 months I have progressive insurance. I lost my down payments 1800 and insurance with on credit balance with progressive 4800$ balance in top of my account. i found out 1800$ his pocket not for insurance company. this was for agent. These people do not help. They need money for them in pocket. They’re playing games with people. I just get car insurance I went emergency and get heart surgery back home i see my car insurance plan is charged for higher prices. I’ve never seen any company have service as bad as Roth & Co. Inc. office. Don’t play with people. Don’t get money with bad service. Karma will follow up with you. We work hard to make our money, you all should be ashamed

Paola Vasquez Loved this business! They’ve been super helpful and nice to me, Eric and Ric are the best! Both super kind and informative about all questions customers have. However I’d stay away from the middle age white lady with the accent, she always rushes you and refuses to help if you ask questions, I wish she could get fired from that great company. ❤️Besides that, I love this insurance company. I highly recommend it! 5 starts ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Matthew DiRusso I can’t say enough good things about my experience with Allstate and Joe’s team! From the very first conversation, they made me feel like a valued client rather than just another policyholder. I needed coverage for both my personal and business insurance, and they took the time to walk me through all my options, answering every question with patience and expertise. Joe and his team genuinely care about their clients, and it shows in the level of service they provide. They were incredibly responsive, always available when I needed assistance, and made the entire process so much easier than I expected. I feel confident knowing I have the right coverage in place, and I truly appreciate their dedication to finding the best solutions for my needs. If you’re looking for an insurance team that is knowledgeable, professional, and actually cares about protecting what matters most to you, I highly recommend giving Joe and his team a call. They’ve earned my trust, and I wouldn’t go anywhere else!

Mansoor Syed “Had an excellent experience with Boris. He is knowledgeable, responsive, and made the entire car/home insurance process smooth and stress-free for me . His attention to detail and personalized advice helped me find the best coverage at a great rate. Highly recommend!”

John Andrews It goes without saying that we all have problems... I can not be more impressed with the kindness sensitivity of an Entire Staff then that of the crew at Nereyda Perez State Farm . Whether its on the phone or in person, professionalism and integrity are well covered here. I have been a client over the past 8 years. Throughout the ebbs and flows ,The Team has been there for me. I must especially mention ..Lorraine, Alex, and Olga. I cant explain enough how they all ..have gone above and beyond for me and my family. I highly recommend this office. From the bottom of my heart. Thank you

Philip Benigno I dont typically write reviews but felt compelled to do so for my go to person at Nereyda Perezs State Farm office. I have been working with Lorraine Taibbi for many years now. My circumstances are never easy with many different policies in force. Lorraine is so knowledgeable and accessible, she always takes care of what needs to be done. Thanks Lorraine!

Cara OShea Terrible service and pricing. Switched to progressive after they bumped my monthly payment up from 250 to 340.

C Frazer They are always friendly, anyone I speak to at the Colin Wheeler agency always takes the time to make sure I understand exactly what is going on regarding what I am asking about. They are appropriately proactive. Extremely knowledgeable. Every interaction with them has been highlt positive. I recommend this agency to anyone for their insurance needs and wants.

oladipupo mesole Huma Faheem serves every customer with a great passion, she has the best interest of customers as her main priority. She is very professional and passionate about customer satisfaction. I recommend her to anyone without hesitation.

Hussain Ali Had the best service from Farwa, she helped in every way possible. She was so patient and truly cares about her clients. Thank you so much for your amazing service.

Yur Khey I had a great experience with Aleph Insurance Agency, Inc. Their team provided excellent service from start to finish. They were professional, knowledgeable, and took the time to answer all my questions thoroughly. I was especially impressed by their competitive pricing — they found me the best coverage options at very reasonable rates. It’s clear they care about their clients and work hard to provide both quality service and value. Highly recommend Aleph Insurance Agency for anyone looking for reliable insurance solutions! Thanks.

Steven Gershkowitz I recently had the pleasure of working with a truly exceptional insurance broker. They consistently prioritized my best interests throughout the entire process, demonstrating a strong commitment to client satisfaction. Their dedication went beyond the typical duties, as they took the time to explain policies in detail and find the best coverage tailored to my needs. They provided expert guidance and support, making the entire experience seamless and stress-free. I wholeheartedly recommend this broker to anyone seeking a reliable and dedicated partner in navigating the insurance landscape. Their expertise in the insurance field and client-centric approach were truly remarkable.

Nadia Godoy Dealing with insurance is usually stressful but working with Emma was a breeze. She was knowledgeable and took the time to explain every detail of my policy. I’m confident I’ve made the right choice in trusting Emma with my coverage.

Nuria Rodríguez I recently worked with Grace Harris to update my insurance, and she was great. She offered valuable advice and helped me choose the best policy for my needs. I appreciate her attention to detail and excellent customer service.

Bryce Pohl Agree with other reviewers that Mary is the most unprofessional and nasty broker. I highly recommend that any potential customers go to another broker. trying to work with Mary was one of the most frustrating and disappointing experiences.

kamal Salfarlie My experience with Ms. McLean and her staff has been above my expectations as a homeowner. Here are 2 of many positive experiences I have had. 1.) At the time, I had Homeowners Insurance with Farmers trough another agent and after reviewing my policy, instead of trying to offer me a policy through her company, she encouraged me to keep my existing policy with Farmers. (Honesty and Trust) 2.) There was a fire in my tenants apartment and she immediately she was able to advise me on the best next steps and recommend an Insurance damage assessment team who worked for me. She also contacted them so I could receive their best compensation rate. They responded quickly and I received more than enough to repair my home. This is the type of Insurance Agent we all need!

Roman T This was my first time purchasing home and auto insurance, Alberto made the process so much easier for me. He explained everything clearly and was a pleasure to work with. He also provided me with the best quotes for both home and auto insurance that no other broker can beat. I definitely recommend Alberto Daniels for all your insurance needs!

Larry Santee Unfortunately I had a claim, but Alberto not only handled it professionally but quickly. After he handled my claim the way he did I ended up switching all my accounts over to his team. Thanks again. 5 stars!!

Injada Hasko Destiny was fantastic, she helped me so much for my commercial auto insurance - she was able to get me the best quote but was also so nice and helpful along the way! Ive recommended her and this state farm location to other business owners!

Igor I had a great experience working with Brandon. He was incredibly helpful and understanding throughout the entire process. He took the time to explain everything to me in a clear and simple way, which made things so much easier to understand. What I really appreciated was his patience—he never rushed me and gave me the time I needed to gather all the necessary paperwork. He even followed up with a reminder call when I missed something, which was so thoughtful and showed how much he truly cares about his clients. Highly recommend!

johnathan cruz The way Luis talks about insurance he truly makes me feel like I’ve been a car guy my whole Life his enthusiasm his excitement u can tell he truly cares about his customers and not only getting them the best deal possible but also educating them as well with certain things. Which it’s cool it’s like not only am I getting a great deal but I’m getting information from a guy who knows his stuff. In the past I’ve dealt with ppl who just try to stiff you to make themselves look good. And it turns u off quickly. If I’m spending my hard earned money, I want it to be with ppl who care. Once I came down in person after speaking on the phone with luis I smiled and soft this is my guy. I had to make the switch from Geico to state. We need more guys like Luis, ultimate car guy!

joe dempsey This office is outright unprofessional There extremely rude They hang up on you when they don’t want to deal with you, i asked them to reopen an audit i have with workers comp and they refuse to open It there the only office that can do It as there office started my policy and they would not help. I have had a rep from State Farm do a 3 way call to try to figure out my situation , They said they would send the docs via email and still never send the docs. Silvana is truly unprofessional and very very rude

Daniel López Nick was the first agent who really listened. He found the perfect policy for me and helped me avoid going over budget.

July The agents took the time to really understand my needs and helped me find a perfect policy. The best part is, they made sure I understood everything along the way.

Malachi Jason Jason I had an amazing experience with Alls Cheap Car Insurance! They truly live up to their name by offering the best cheap car insurance without sacrificing quality. The team was friendly, knowledgeable, and made the whole process fast and stress-free. I saved a lot of money and got excellent coverage. Highly recommend them to anyone looking for affordable and reliable car insurance options!

porter harry I didn’t expect my first car insurance policy to be this simple. On the way back from Miller Field, I saw All’s Cheap Car Insurance right on New Dorp Lane and decided to stop in. Being a new driver, I assumed budget-friendly auto insurance might mean less coverage, but they proved me wrong. They walked me through liability vs. full coverage, explained the deductible in plain English, and gave me a monthly premium I could actually afford without losing protection. I walked out with my proof of insurance the same day, smiling like I’d passed another exam. They even shared advice on keeping rates low over time. Finding a team this kind and helpful is rare, so I’m sticking with them for renewals.

Galina Moiseyeva Professional, kind, very fast responded to any problem, get my insurance in One day time, Tim resolve all issue very fast and professional. Highly recommended .

Eduard M Spoke to Tim, easy to work with, helped get me the best coverage and rates!

Sheila Langilotti I chose this agency simply because I was his nurse the whole time he was ill. Ive been with them a long time. The employee entered the claim for me and gave me the adjusters name. I have been calling for 3 weeks without a call back. This is more a bad review at the adjuster not the agency. They are helpful and pleasant. And I will register a complaint against that adjuster. Discovered the problem, I must have given them the wrong cell#. All has been rectified, very quickly I might add. They really are very nice and try to help in any way they can.

Patrick Egan The very best Norman was awesome R.i.p. 40 years ago....

Kellie Boykin Im going to keep it short and simple. The agency has the most unprofessional and RACIST staff. I was purchasing a new car and was trying to get assistance with combining 2 car onto my policy and the lady(refused to give her name) was extremely rude and unhelpful. Old school Italians people that work there that still think all people of color are uneducated and unsuccessful

Christina Lonuzzi Quick, efficient and cost effective this agency offers customer service that goes above and beyond. Extremely responsive and informative. They are the real deal! I certainly recommend them for all your Insurance needs.

Emanuel Excellent service from start to finish. The agent gave me helpful recommendations that were easy to understand and very relevant to my situation.

Josefina noemi Sánchez peña I’ve tried several insurance companies over the years but none of them compare to the service I’ve received here. The agents are professional, responsive and genuinely care about helping you get the right coverage.

Natalia Zaikina Great Agency! John Di Forte is very nice and professional. He helped us to get a general liability insurance for our small business although many insurance companies denied us.The price of the policy was acceptable to us, and Johnny included in the policy all the necessary conditions. We are very thankful and recommend this agency to all!

Carol LaPeruta Excellent customer service.