new-york Date: 08-31-2025

19 Best Insurance Services in Syracuse, NY

AgentcyAddress
1Independent Insurance NY709 Erie Blvd W, Syracuse, NY 13204
2The Hartford201 E Jefferson St Ste 308, Syracuse, NY 13202
3Donigan Business and Personal Insurance708 W Belden Ave Box 11535, Syracuse, NY 13204
4Firm Insurance Agency, LLC - Masterpole Murphy Insurance - East5900 N Burdick St, East Syracuse, NY 13057
5Lori Myers - GEICO Insurance Agent2528 Erie Blvd E 1st Floor, Syracuse, NY 13224
6John L Spencer II: Allstate Insurance1367 Burnet Ave, Syracuse, NY 13206
7Haylor, Freyer & Coon Inc.300 S State St #1000, Syracuse, NY 13202
8CH Insurance100 S Salina St #370, Syracuse, NY 13202
9Stagnitta Insurance Agency Inc3312 James St, Syracuse, NY 13206
10Brenda Flagg - State Farm Insurance Agent306 E 1st St, East Syracuse, NY 13057
11Delmonico Insurance Agency720 Van Rensselaer St Suite 207, Syracuse, NY 13204
12Liverpool Associates701 N State St, Syracuse, NY 13203
13Farmers Insurance - Colleen McCawley100 E Manlius St, East Syracuse, NY 13057
14Affordable McLaughlin Kehoe Insurance Agency225 W Manlius St, East Syracuse, NY 13057
15Pat Best - State Farm Insurance Agent201 N Townsend St, Syracuse, NY 13203
16Don Marsh Agency, Inc.4875 South Ave, Syracuse, NY 13215
17Sitka Insurance Agency, INC212 E Manlius St, East Syracuse, NY 13057
18business insurance rochester, ny | liability insurance rochester ny | steve donigan agency708 W Belden Ave, Syracuse, NY 13204
19Salanger and Hayward Agency3700 James St, Syracuse, NY 13206

1.Independent Insurance NY

Address: 709 Erie Blvd W, Syracuse, NY 13204

(5) Clients Are Saying about:

iferch I’ve had insurance for years, but I’ve never experienced the level of service I’ve had here. They were fast in getting my coverage set up, and their team was professional and friendly. It’s great to know that I have a team I can rely on when I need them most.
5 /5
MinPatricia Rodriguez This agency made everything so easy. They found me better protection at a price that actually fits my budget. I’m happy I made the switch
5 /5

2.The Hartford

Address: 201 E Jefferson St Ste 308, Syracuse, NY 13202

(5) Clients Are Saying about:

Brian Koehler This company is a joke. Try to get anything done on the customer service line and try not to lose your mind. The worst experience Ive had with any claim. They want you to give up so they can keep your money. Also why do yall have 3 reviews. Deleting the bad ones eh?
1 /5
Erica Williams Sad to see that is not just me who is going through this, I will now be contacting a lawyer. My parked car was hit by someone with your insurance almost 2 weeks ago and NOTHING. No phone call, no email, I had to call yesterday. Finally got a claim number and a claim adjuster. Left her a message this morning and NOTHING. You should be ashamed.
1 /5

3.Donigan Business and Personal Insurance

Address: 708 W Belden Ave Box 11535, Syracuse, NY 13204

(487) Clients Are Saying about:

Vernesa Merdanovic Worked with Jeanelle on a home insurance quote - found us the best rate we received! Super fast, professional, and responsive. Highly recommend!
5 /5
Raymond Card Lynns professionalism is exceptional. She is pleasant and mindful. Lynne is one of the persons that make the Donigan insurance company a great place to buy insurance.
5 /5

4.Firm Insurance Agency, LLC - Masterpole Murphy Insurance - East

Address: 5900 N Burdick St, East Syracuse, NY 13057

images Firm Insurance Agency, LLC - Masterpole Murphy Insurance - East

(38) Clients Are Saying about:

Lindsay Stone I have had a few different insurance providers and none compare to Patricia Oot with Firm Insurance. She has the clients best interest and makes it clear she works for you. She makes herself available to give personal advice, walk through different scenarios, and explain the why. If the car insurance industry is a black box to you and you want to feel like a human being, work with Firm Insurance.
5 /5
Charles Helmer Firm Insurance Agency has been an invaluable partner for my business insurance needs. Their tailored solutions, competitive rates, and exceptional customer service have provided me with peace of mind. I highly recommend Firm Insurance Agency to any business owner seeking reliable insurance coverage. Thank you, Firm Insurance Agency, for your dedication and support.
5 /5

5.Lori Myers - GEICO Insurance Agent

Address: 2528 Erie Blvd E 1st Floor, Syracuse, NY 13224

(373) Clients Are Saying about:

Melissa Parmentier Lynne was absolutely fabulous at helping me find more affordable insurance. She walked me through the different options and ways I can save even more money!
5 /5
Dawn Compton Well they still took money out of my account and when I re done my registration they told dmv that they canceled my policy and never reinstated me until April with no reason no mail no nothing and never got anything from dmv either but they still took money out and I had to be without a car for 66 days they are liars and make people struggle I got new insurance and way cheaper than geico
1 /5

6.John L Spencer II: Allstate Insurance

Address: 1367 Burnet Ave, Syracuse, NY 13206

(37) Clients Are Saying about:

Arun S John is an amazing human who loves to help, courteous and lend his hand through every step of the process. His positive attitude to customers is commendable! If you are looking for an Allstate agent in NY state, John is the perfect choice!
5 /5
Serle Frederiksen I like this Allstate agency. John and Karin were very helpful and we decided to move all our insurance to them. They are able to do it all - house, car, ATV, boat and life insurance. Im sure they are able to do more as well. We have been very happy with the quality of customer service and straight up answers. Its a breath of fresh air. I would highly recommend them.
5 /5

7.Haylor, Freyer & Coon Inc.

Address: 300 S State St #1000, Syracuse, NY 13202

(366) Clients Are Saying about:

Rickie Hatlee As always, MURANDA, my agent, working with my car insurance, is exceptionally wonderful! I would recommend this company and give it 10 Stars if I could! MURANDA is just a gem, she is efficient, pleasant and the nicest person to do business with.. Im so glad I found this company.. definitely TOP NOTCH!! Even when I call the 800 number, EVERYONE is ALWAYS efficient and pleasant to deal with.
5 /5
Helen Henson They called me to improve my vehicle coverage. They are a great company. Mr. "Bud" Haylor was a great person, also. I am not surprised that the employees comprise a thoughtful company.
5 /5

8.CH Insurance

Address: 100 S Salina St #370, Syracuse, NY 13202

(351) Clients Are Saying about:

Cherie Cooper Diane Nies has worked with us over the last few years with our insurance needs. She has been wonderful! But when an issue for our daughter arose she was nothing but amazing even sitting in her car with no power working on a deal for us, that is truly above and beyond. If you need insurance call her!! Thank you Diane!!
5 /5
Howard Jones I have been dealing with Diane Nies, and have been extremely satisfied with the level of service she provides. Diane understands the insurance industry extremely well, and was fantastic at finding me the policys that I needed without all of the extra add-ons. Diane is extremely pleasant to work with, and attentive to questions and problem. Diane is an ambassador for CH Insurance, and she is the reason I will continue to take my insurance business to CH Insurance.
5 /5

9.Stagnitta Insurance Agency Inc

Address: 3312 James St, Syracuse, NY 13206

(3) Clients Are Saying about:

Mark Haynes Go by there tonight go in
3 /5
Jim Roberts Thieves!!
1 /5

10.Brenda Flagg - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 306 E 1st St, East Syracuse, NY 13057

(286) Clients Are Saying about:

minet schindehutte Everyone knows State Farm is one of the top insurance companies. However, unless you are a clients at the Brenda Flagg agency, you do not yet know that State Farm is the BEST. What makes them special is people like Kristyn who goes above and beyond to make sure my requests/questions are answered quickly, professionally and precisely. Kristyn makes me feel that she takes a personal interest in my insurance needs, and that Staye Farm has my back. Choosing State Farm has been one of my best decisions…
5 /5
Melissa Harkavy Ive been a customer with Brenda for years and always returned for her team’s stellar customer service. They are always super responsive and informative, and they make the process so easy. I love that I can call them up and always receive a helpful answer. Fiona was especially amazing today! She walked us through our policy renewal and she even found a few discounts for us.
5 /5

11.Delmonico Insurance Agency

Address: 720 Van Rensselaer St Suite 207, Syracuse, NY 13204

(270) Clients Are Saying about:

Sharen Sweiki Katy Melnick was absolutely phenomenal! Me and my husband Samir just switched from different agency and we had the pleasure of working with Katy! She was quick, honest and took the time to explain everything to us! We really appreciate her help! She found us a great deal. 10/10 service! Thanks again Katy for an outstanding experience!
5 /5
Alexis Oropallo Everyone I’ve dealt with has been amazing! They are very responsive on email, text, or call. Nikki handled a tricky situation very quickly for me. I’ve moved multiple times and I’ve never had an issue. They take care of everything for me. 10/10
5 /5

12.Liverpool Associates

Address: 701 N State St, Syracuse, NY 13203

(27) Clients Are Saying about:

Tasha Jones Been here for years and they have kept me as a happy customer great job everyone!
5 /5
Jacqueline Love I was a loyal customer for years and I was rear ended by a police officer some years ago and Liverpool associates/nationwide insurance screwed me over and I was injured. They never went after the responsible party, and they stopped covering my medical bills.
1 /5

13.Farmers Insurance - Colleen McCawley

Address: 100 E Manlius St, East Syracuse, NY 13057

images Farmers Insurance - Colleen McCawley

(26) Clients Are Saying about:

kal alston The agency has been responsive and timely when issues have arisen. The agents are professional and able to direct me through the claims process.
5 /5
Lorraine P Everyone from Greg Lambert who prepared our policy to our claims rep., Mike Allard were so kind and patient with myself and my husband. They were just wonderful and so appreciated. I recommend all my friends to Greg.
5 /5

14.Affordable McLaughlin Kehoe Insurance Agency

Address: 225 W Manlius St, East Syracuse, NY 13057

(25) Clients Are Saying about:

George They always find me great rates & answer all of my questions.
5 /5
Anthony Young I am currently represented by your company and I understand that a lot of people dont usually take the time to write a review unless the experience was unsatisfactory and I dont take any personal pleasure in doing such! I have been a customer of yours for a number of years without incident. 2 months ago my vehicle was no longer drivable, so I took it off of the road and canceled the insurance because (shrugs) I had nothing to insure... Yesterday my girlfriend contacted your company because I now have a new vehicle, we were being assisted by diana who pulled the wrong vehicle file, a vehicle I havent had in 6 years or so and charged us a fee, and then abruptly closed and went home without our knowledge... Today we had everything straightened out, or so I thought...when I arrived to sign paperwork and get photos taken of the new vehicle, after all the paperwork was organized diana then told me that because I did not keep paying insurance even though I had nothing to insure, I am now going to have to pay double of what I would have if I kept paying for insurance mind you with nothing to ensure?? Now policies are policies I get that but as a CONSULTANT why wasnt I told this when I canceled because it would be a "no brainer" to keep paying to keep my rate reasonable?? I am a logical person I just dont understand how this is fair and when I asked diana I was told and I quote "we dont have to tell you anything" "if you cancel your insurance, thats your prerogative"!! This is less of a complaint and more of a WARNING!! Keep paying these companies even if theres nothing to insure because if not you will pay dearly after!! I feel I was ignorant to such unfair policies and taken advantage of please help me understand otherwise!!
1 /5

15.Pat Best - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 201 N Townsend St, Syracuse, NY 13203

(23) Clients Are Saying about:

James Walker Pat Best is the absolute wost! After I informed her that I was canceling my insurace with her company she never submitted the cancelation and in turn charged my BAnk Account and told me tere was nothing she could do. It has litterly taken half my day to get this resolved.
1 /5
Kiva VanDerGeest Pat Best and her family are the BEST! It has meant more than I ever knew it would to have them as my guardian angels as I move through all my life changing decisions, big purchases, and those moments where you just need a kind voice to help you move forward. I"m so glad to have this group in my community and as my insurance agent.
5 /5

16.Don Marsh Agency, Inc.

Address: 4875 South Ave, Syracuse, NY 13215

(22) Clients Are Saying about:

Meg Notes Don Marsh Agency, Inc. is excellent! I Googled “Medicare Brokers,” read the reviews, and called for an appointment. I live in Syracuse and was pleased to find that their offices were within five miles of my home. I have dealt with Jackie, Tina Holgate, and Paul Holgate. They are all friendly, welcoming, and provide exemplary customer service. Paul and Tina handle Medicare enrollment and all things Medicare. I’m almost 65 and knew very little about enrolling, but Paul is extremely knowledgeable. In about two hours, I was enrolled in what I felt was the best plan for my needs. Paul made it easy! I highly, highly recommend the Don Marsh Agency, Inc. for Medicare Enrollment. You CANNOT go wrong here!
5 /5
Holley cunningham Sandy and Susan are amazing! I have been using these ladies for 3 years. Theyre willing to help me with any questions anytime , day or night. I highly recommend to anyone who is looking for a great rate on insurance and wants personal friendly , customer service. You wont be disappointed
5 /5

17.Sitka Insurance Agency, INC

Address: 212 E Manlius St, East Syracuse, NY 13057

(219) Clients Are Saying about:

Mike Van Riper I have been with Sitka for a couple years and have been. Wet happy with them. Hannah is always on top of everything for me. She is very responsive, she works quickly to address whatever I need, she’s always accurate, and she’s an awesome to work with. I can’t say enough about the awesome service I get with Hannah and Sitka Insurance. Everyone should be calling them!!
5 /5
Kyle Johnson I’ve had an amazing experience with Sitka insurance. Sarah handles my account and has been more than helpful with everything I’ve needed and made the process very simple. She was able to get my auto insurance to a price lower than what I payed last year even after I had an accident. Couldn’t be more thankful for them.
5 /5

18.business insurance rochester, ny | liability insurance rochester ny | steve donigan agency

Address: 708 W Belden Ave, Syracuse, NY 13204

(20) Clients Are Saying about:

Wendy J Ptaszek I always get taken care of very well at the steve donigan agency his staff has always been very helpful to me for many years and always gotten me the best insurance thanks a lot to your staff and you steve!
5 /5
Erica Aller I have been with the Donigan agency for a number of years now and they are great especially Natoshia! Every time I have called or emailed for questions or changing over vehicles/ATVs or even an accident she gets right back to me and takes care of everything. Its nice to just send over my issue or request and know that it will be quickly taken care of so I dont have to worry about it.
5 /5

19.Salanger and Hayward Agency

Address: 3700 James St, Syracuse, NY 13206