Keywords: insurance_agency,point_of_interest,establishment

True Insurance - Ithaca (NY)

Address: 🏡 124 Seneca Way, Ithaca, NY 14850

Phone : +1 (607) 273-7511

Weekly Open time

Place GG: https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJ9aOJPpuB0IkRJVBIc_MNRso

Where is True Insurance 🏡?
124 Seneca Way, Ithaca, NY 14850
What is the phone number True Insurance 📱?
(607) 273-7511
What Clients Are Saying about True Insurance (on GG)

1 /5 Riann Nova: Be aware if youre moving out of state and using True insurance. Ive been a customer for over a decade, and have moved out of state several times with no issues-- Until now. True is now refusing to cancel my policy and is making me pay for my current NY policy PLUS my new policy in the new state I moved to, until they can receive PROOF FROM THE DMV that I turned your plates in. Ive talked to several insurance representatives from other companies ( including one from Erie Insurance who is my actual provider) who all say this should NOT be the case and that I have the right to cancel my policy at any time I want to. According to True, this is ONLY their policy and has nothing to do with the DMV nor my actual insurance provider. So unless you want to get completely screwed by having to pay for 2 insurance policies at the same time, LEAVE THIS COMPANY IMMEDIATELY.

5 /5 Megan Barber: My wife and I have been very pleased with all of our dealings with True Insurance. They have been handling our home and auto insurance for a number of years now. We have found their pricing to be very competitive and the two claims weve filed, one auto and one home, were handled quickly and to our complete satisfaction.

5 /5 David P: Use a local Insurance agent. True answers the phone when I call, I speak to a very nice human and they deal with my giant Insurance corporation for me. I have been a True customer since 1990. I stay because of the great customer service. Unfortunately, my son recently had a deer vs. car accident (all ok, except the deer). True has been fantastic in dealing with the whole matter. The claim, follow-up, and subsequent new used car purchase. Their responses and interactions are all upbeat and amazingly quick. I am not only a lifelong customer, but my 20-year-old son has seen the value of a local agent. They has made a crappy situation much better.

5 /5 aleta weaver: I have been with True now for about 7 years. I switched because they found me car and house insurance for half what I was paying. I check often and True is always the best. And I had to make a claim once and they were quick at dealing with it and my rates didnt go up. They are the best. Tell them I referred you and I get a free bagel!They are the best!

5 /5 Ann Wexler: We’ve been using True insurance for five year for both home and auto. Excellent service. Prompt returns of calls and helpful with questions, and very reasonable prices. No claims so far but we expect helpful service if we ever do have one
Convenient Location
GG map: https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJ9aOJPpuB0IkRJVBIc_MNRso

Others Near Ithaca,NY

10 Best Insurance Services in Ithaca, NY:Our Top 20 Picks

08-2025 True Insurance in 10 Best Insurance Services in Ithaca, NY:Our Top 20 Picks

12 Recommended Insurance Agencies in Ithaca, NY

08-2025 True Insurance in 12 Recommended Insurance Agencies in Ithaca, NY

Freeway Insurance - Ithaca

Jeffrey Velardi: I was treated with world class customer service from Kimberly Poorman. She walked us through everything and it was smooth and easy! Great Job excellent employee! Freeway Insurance has a great staff! Thank you Kimberly!

Andrews Agency Insurance - Ithaca

Joanne Willcox: Highly recommend the Andrews Agency! We recently needed coverage in a rush and Phil was amazing! He had us quoted and bound in less than 24 hours. Thank you!!

Nick Romo - State Farm Insurance Agent - Ithaca

Raymond Carruthers: We relocated from California to Upstate New York, moving 2 cars and buying 2houses. Nick and his team were very helpful in getting us through that transition. They worked to get us appropriate coverage which was tricky as we did a lot of building improvements. At the same time they improved our coverage they also helped us eliminate coverage that we didn’t need, saving us money. Besides being helpful and efficient, they were also upbeat and friendly. We recommend them highly if you are in need of insurance coverage.

Bailey Place Insurance - Ithaca

Doug Bentley: We have policies covering four vehicles and two residences. This week we were invited in to update some information so that we could look into the possibility of lowering our overall premium cost for all that coverage. Susie Dunn, our account manager was most courteous. And . . . we were treated to free coffee from Coffee Mania!

Zach Clark - State Farm Insurance Agent - Ithaca

Rich Rasmussen: It is no surprise that Zach Clark and his team were voted best insurance company in Ithaca and Tompkins county. Super knowledgeable, friendly, great attention to detail and incredibly helpful. Mark was my agent who helped with small business insurance and took his time to provide detailed answers to my questions. The rate was also amazing and super competitive. I highly recommend giving them a call for any of your insurance needs.

Nationwide Insurance: Anthony W Burchell - Ithaca

Mel Solomon: Burchell agency recently took over the Nationwide office in Ithaca after Stan Barlow retired. I am just getting to know the agents in the office. Recently without me contacting them, Nikki called me and said there may be new ratings that Nationwide has introduced for auto insurance and would I mind if she re-did a quote for me. In a few days I got a call from her saying that my premium would go down over $200 for 6 months. Could I use the $200? You bet! What agent would call a customer to voluntarily reduce pricing? A good agent, thats who. Thank you Nationwide insurance. And thank you Nikki and the Burchell agency.

Adam Megivern - State Farm Insurance Agent - Ithaca

Tiana P: I had an amazing experience working with Anthony for my auto insurance. From the start, he was incredibly knowledgeable and took the time to explain all my coverage options without any pressure. He helped me find a policy that not only fit my budget but also offered better coverage than what I had before. Communication was fast and clear—every question I had was answered right away. It’s rare to find someone who’s both professional and genuinely cares about their clients. I highly recommend Anthony D Henry to anyone looking for a trustworthy, responsive insurance agent!

State Farm: Lee Newhart Jr - Ithaca

Genesis Romero: Thank you to Nadine for her kindness and willingness to help!

Moscato & Associates Inc - Ithaca

Kirk Macolini: Barbara Brenner at Moscato & Associates helped me with my company’s health insurance for over a decade. Navigating health insurance for small businesses can be challenging and Barbara was always helpful. I found her competent, helpful, and she always seems to have my company and employees’ best interests in mind!

The Becker-Well Agency, Inc. - Ithaca

AMY LANZILOTTA: I have been using Becker-Wells since i began driving over 20 years ago. The ladies in the office have been wonderful and are always willing to check different carriers out for me and provide comparisons. I recall when I began driving, Linda set me up with a carrier until i had a couple years of driving under my belt. Then she signed me up with NYCM which has amazing rates. Very Happy!!!