new-york Date: 07-01-2025

Best 11 Churches in NY Near Geneseo

Church NameAddress
1Saint Michaels Church23 Main St, Geneseo, NY 14454
2The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints42 E South St, Geneseo, NY 14454
3Pleasant Valley Baptist Church4631 Lakeville Rd, Geneseo, NY 14454
4St Timothy Lutheran Church5015 Lakeville Rd, Geneseo, NY 14454
5Cornerstone Baptist Church4232 Reservoir Rd, Geneseo, NY 14454
6Geneseo United Methodist Church4520 Genesee St, Geneseo, NY 14454
7Christ Community Church26 Center St, Geneseo, NY 14454
8St Mary Catholic Church4 Avon Geneseo Rd, Geneseo, NY 14454
9Central Presbyterian Church31 Center St, Geneseo, NY 14454
10St. Luke the Evangelist Parish Center13 North St, Geneseo, NY 14454
11LightStream Church2 Haley Ave, Geneseo, NY 14454

1.Saint Michaels Church

Address: 23 Main St, Geneseo, NY 14454

images Saint Michaels Church

Reviewed by the Communit (8):

Victor Ventura A very beautiful church
5 /5
Judith Day My home church, in every sense of the word. Come and see for yourself. We welcome all.
5 /5
Curt Grant Feels great going there ...
5 /5

2.The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Address: 42 E South St, Geneseo, NY 14454

images The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Reviewed by the Communit (17):

Ben Buchmiller Awesome that this village has built a new church building and is no longer meeting in the building near Walmart (now H&R Block). I attended this congregation late 2006 and a few months in early 2007.
5 /5
Brent Powell I love attending church here. The teachings are Christ centered and help me improve who I am, which improves all aspects of my life. Ive felt welcome and comfortable since the first day I attended here in 2008. The people are friendly and though they are a diverse group in styles and backgounds they are united and supportive.
5 /5
Bracken Allen Its a great congregation with a great message to share! One of the newest LDS buildings in WNY, and it is beautiful inside. Really, though, its not the building that matters but the feeling that is there, and the Geneseo Ward has a great feel to it!
5 /5

3.Pleasant Valley Baptist Church

Address: 4631 Lakeville Rd, Geneseo, NY 14454

images Pleasant Valley Baptist Church

Reviewed by the Communit (11):

ATasha Lynn Great place, wonderful people. Def recommend
5 /5
snyder Debra (Debo) Love it free clothing on whensday has helped me get smaller sizes from weight loss
5 /5
Tricia Cliburn Everyone was so nice and welcoming I would go there again
5 /5

4.St Timothy Lutheran Church

Address: 5015 Lakeville Rd, Geneseo, NY 14454

images St Timothy Lutheran Church

Reviewed by the Communit (16):

Andrew Gookin Did some worship here. Great feel. Welcome and safe for all. Pastor Deb is the best too!!!!
4 /5
Kandy St Tim’s provided free garden areas for people to tend. A wonderful opportunity for folks to keep the cost of food down. A thankful opportunity. Blessed be! and many thanks. It helped many people.
5 /5
S B They share a community garden with others! Each person gets a large raised garden box to grow and care for their own veggies,herbs or flowers!
5 /5

5.Cornerstone Baptist Church

Address: 4232 Reservoir Rd, Geneseo, NY 14454

images Cornerstone Baptist Church

Reviewed by the Communit (13):

Douglas Kenyon Good sermon and people special handicap can be in the parking lot has radio set up 91.9 can hear the church service
5 /5
Broc Burkhow Very nice people and great pastor. Good sound doctrine and great location.
5 /5
Robert Enjoyed my talk with pastor john
4 /5

6.Geneseo United Methodist Church

Address: 4520 Genesee St, Geneseo, NY 14454

Reviewed by the Communit (23):

Kandy United Methodist Outreach. Is a great place to go when your looking for medical& dental outreach when you’re underserved and don’t have enough money to pay the high prices for dental services or medical co-pays.
4 /5
David Ebersole They let us use their space for our Boy Scout meetings. Very nice of them. Thanks!
5 /5
Chuck Harty They really do reach out for people in need. Health food spiritual healing. They go beyond
5 /5

7.Christ Community Church

Address: 26 Center St, Geneseo, NY 14454

Reviewed by the Communit (13):

Maggie White Love this church. Small and personal WITH a great kids program. Have finally found someplace that my grandkids and I really enjoy.
4 /5
Naomi My husband and I attend regularly and love this Church. Were a young couple and the community of friends that become like family here is amazing. There is a variety of ages of people in the church. The teaching is wonderful and there are a variety of areas to sign up and help in. A wonderful Church that truly cares for others. I urge anyone to come and experience a service!
5 /5
Joanie Baird Always the best place to go too....if you cant find it here you wont find it anywhere !
5 /5

8.St Mary Catholic Church

Address: 4 Avon Geneseo Rd, Geneseo, NY 14454

Reviewed by the Communit (26):

Alexander Crilly Beautiful church, amazing people
5 /5
Anthony Pirrone In terms of management, absolute embarrassment of a church. They will give mass times on signs outside the door and on their website, and then simply not host them. For example, this Easter Sunday, their website said they would be having a service at 8:00am, as did the sign outside. After a long walk, I arrived to a closed church. People were with me, also wondering why the church was closed. A similar thing happened during Ash Wednesday. Their signs are completely incorrect. Its a shame, because its a beautiful church. I will be visiting the Lutheran church from now on. At least their services are when they say they are.
1 /5
Kandy A good day to vote in the primaries. Parking is right next to the building. Easy to get in & easy to get out. Don’t forget to VOTE! It’s your right, use it.
5 /5

9.Central Presbyterian Church

Address: 31 Center St, Geneseo, NY 14454

Reviewed by the Communit (14):

Linnette Maxson Our pastor is brilliant (Ph.D. in chemistry, a Greek and Hebrew scholar), and when she talks about God, her face glows and joy inhabits her voice. . From September to May she holds a Bible study group every Monday morning where she fills us in on history, geography and cultural mores of the time. Normally we have 15 to 20 people there, not all of them from our church. Our congregation is welcoming, we love little kids, we house the local food pantry and this year are growing a community garden. ( Ive never seen kale look so good. ) Our music director is dedicated to the church and the community. Every spring we host a series of organ recitals that are very popular. Our choir is small but enthusiastic, and our handbell choir works hard to play 6 or 8 times each year. Come and worship with us, and stay for cookies and fruit afterwards.
5 /5
Shana E Very beautiful church and everyone is so very welcoming. A great community church! Also has a large free food pantry for those who could use it!
5 /5
Diana Cassidy Ive had to go here for help with food due to pandemic... The volunteers were extremely nice and didnt make me feel less than! It is difficult asking for help, for me it is! Thank you so much!! God bless you ALL
5 /5

10.St. Luke the Evangelist Parish Center

Address: 13 North St, Geneseo, NY 14454

Reviewed by the Communit (7):

Kandy Works great for voting. Drive in, park & leave.
4 /5
Dan Mullin A wonderful parish to join
5 /5

11.LightStream Church

Address: 2 Haley Ave, Geneseo, NY 14454