Best 13 Jewelry Stores Near You Ithaca, NY

Ashley Ulacco I am so impressed with the quality and talent here! They were able to work with me to trade in broken gold pieces to fix a sentimental necklace. They were efficient and had great communication. How special the shop is and fortunate I walked in to begin with! Side note: lovely unique jewelry selection caught my eye while I was in the shop!

Carter Hall Thank you so much Justin!! He helped me and my fiancé pick out the perfect wedding ring! A very kind and knowledgeable manager. He even complimented the rings I had on, which belonged to my fiancé’s grandmother. Justin knows style, and he really made us feel comfortable in our decision! Thanks again from Carter and Elbe

Peter Jones This is run by charming woman who knows everything about each piece on sale in her store. My wife and I before we had children had bought some Christmas ornaments here which we still put on our tree and dearly love. It is still the same shop and The same owner. We were offered bottled water when we arrived which was very nice for the warm day. We ended up buying some chocolates which were exceptional and I was able to get a delightful Mother’s Day gift for my wife. I highly recommend a trip to 15 steps.

Bridget Daugherty-Costa Such gorgeous jewelry. In love with the necklace I bought here !

Dionysys Entertainer The highest quality craftsmanship of handmade jewelry

Kate Browning Schooley’s was awesome. I personally chose them over other jewelers after feeling like other stores treated shoppers with higher budgets with more attention and courtesy. Dave was incredibly nice and everyone else in the store was very welcoming. I had three pieces: 1) a loose mystery stone from my mother that I thought was glass 2) an old aquamarine ring that I inherited from my grandmother and 3) an engagement ring that was too big. The loose stone was actually an aquamarine and I had it made into a pendant. Dave was awesome throughout the entire process and I love the final product. I asked for the ring to be resized after contemplating having it reset — and even though it was less money for Schooley’s they respected my decision that the original setting was sentimental to me. The ring is amazing and so clean I hardly recognized it My engagement ring was resized in just a few days and is flawless as well. Overall 10/10 and 5 stars :)

Jacob Yahiayan One of my few favorite places. Its Gods gift. I only wish we had the same in Southampton, New York. Thank you Clark family.

DJ A hidden gem in Ithaca. The reason I said its hidden is because the store is inside a building plaza. The store is not big but you can still find so many goodies. Just like the name, everything reminds you the past and will bring you back in time. You can find old jewelry, clothing, postcards, books, hats, toys and many more!

Nunia Busines Seems to house art from local artists- the people working there were very nice and let me buy something after they put up the closed sign. There are lots of gem stones, but I liked it for the original illustrations different artists made in print and sticker form. Gave me a sweet little bag to put my merchandise in. The only thing I would critique is that there was a basket of stickers that seemed like they werent made by artists here and were instead taken from third parties, like Totoro stuff. The hours the store is open are also currently a bit up in the air, but I hope one day in the future, they can find a viable schedule.

Elizabeth Van Loan Fareed cleaned the engagement ring I inherited and he created a wedding band to match it. He did an amazing job. I highly recommend going to Carla Bijouterie Gallery.

Ben Pichel We had a great experience with Peter! So professional and friendly. My fiancée and I bought our wedding bands from him, he was extremely helpful and timely in finding us the rings we wanted. Couldn’t be happier with our purchase!

Abby Grassick My fiancé and I had a wonderful experience working with Mansour for our engagement. Mike and his team provided a beautiful custom ring and above-and-beyond customer service! I could not recommend them more to anyone in the area.

Olivia Tolliver Great experience. Stopped by to have a watch battery replaced. Super kind staff and the staff member changed the watch battery right in front of me. 15$ and less than 5 minutes.