Caffe’ Maya - Herkimer (NY)

5 /5 Joe Rocco: Excellent Italian food ! Had an antipasto and chicken parm….was outstanding! Staff and owner very nice people. Can bring your own wine. Will definitely be back.

5 /5 Cynthia Dite Sirni: Christian is a master because the food is absolutely top notch. The dishes are both inventive and old school, made with the freshest ingredients. There is a separate dining area perfect for business lunches, showers, or larger get togethers. His staff are beautiful. Santina and Philomena welcomed us like family. Christian himself moved between the kitchen and dining room checking on his guests and appearing with food. He should have a Michelin Star in NYC but we are blessed to have him here. It feels like eating at Nonna’s but with an elegant city vibe. Delicious.

5 /5 Baked Beans Forge: With our last night in Herkimer, we decided to end it was a nice casual dinner. We were so glad we found this little gem. Everything was fantastic. I had the lobster ravioli and my wife had the gnocchi with meat ball. We added a plate of sauté lings hots with some x sharp provolone, See you next year!

2 /5 Melissa Childers: We made reservations for NYE here at least a month in advance and were looking forward to dining here as we had heard so many positive reviews on the Italian food here. Once we arrived we were both deeply disappointed to be given a VERY limited menu with not even one pasta option. As a new restaurant to our area, you should have made it known to patrons you would not have your regular menu available.. this is NOT how you earn trust from patrons. Needless to say.. neither my husband or myself could agree on any of the options on this limited menu and we left and took our money elsewhere. I do not believe we will be giving this restaurant another opportunity.

5 /5 June Ciulla: Would highly recommend this place! Food was absolutely delicious. Staff were so kind and the atmosphere is lovely. Will definitely be back! Also got some provolone to-go as they also have a deli with many items!