Coral Bay Cafe - Staten Island (NY)

4 /5 David G.: My wife came to the restaurant for the first time. We are big seafood lovers. We ordered a cheese platter, clams on the half shell, seafood salad, and Scungilli over linguine in a red hot sauce. We shared everything. Everything was delicious. My wife felt that the clams were not fresh, but I disagreed with her. I thought the portion was a little small for the prices, but everything now a days cost a lot. The wine selection was adequate, per glass, and bottle prices were a little high. The menu was huge a lot of choices. The dessert was very good, and Cappachino was so-so. Was surprised to see they did NOT charge you extra for using a credit card. That surprised me. Because every other restaurant does. I would definitely come back and other seafood items. Service was perfect, location perfect. No wait.

4 /5 Frank Castellano: We had to sit outside because my cousin had the dog with them, but it was very good until the sun went down and the mosquitoes came out to feast on us. The food was very good and the server,Kimberly, was so nice. Appetizers were the usual fried calamari, baked clams and cheese stuffed zucchini flowers. All very tasty. Entrees of pasta with clams,shrimp and broccoli rabe, shrimp francese, clams over fusilli and my incredible pork chop parmigian that was the size of a tomahawk steak! We all enjoyed it and even took some home. Coral Bay Cafe was very good and I would return again, but definitely bring mosquito repellent if youre looking to dine " AL fresco"

5 /5 Samantha Taranto: I recently had the pleasure of dining at Coral Bay Cafe, and I must say it was a great experience. The service was top-notch, with a friendly and attentive staff who went above and beyond to ensure our dining satisfaction. The calamari was simply fantastic. It was cooked to perfection, crispy and golden. The oysters were fresh and delicious too. All the special appetizers were great. Thank you for a wonderful dinner.

5 /5 N Podpiska: This is an exceptional location on the bay. Surprising, romantic, amazingly tasty, cozy, not expensive for this level of cuisine. It is so delicious that there are no words! Cafe in a quiet residential area. Good for dinner! It is definitely worth a visit and you will definitely add it to your list of your favorite places!