Ficarellas Pizzeria - Batavia (NY)

5 /5 Gary R. Wolanske: Im from out of town but I order pizza and wings every year at Christmas and the staff is super Pleasant and theyre very helpful and the pizza and wings are very yummy

2 /5 Truth Seeker: Great garbage plates, though sadly I had to wait almost 2 hours to get it, my fat wrap wasnt in the bag, the food was cold, the garbage plate had the wrong contents. Had to wait an additional 30+ minutes just to get the rest of my food. On a good day Id say go for it.

3 /5 Rhonda Weldy: 10/31/25. Ordered sheet pizza and 64 bonless wings. Crust for pizza was to thick and ingredients were sliding off. Boneless wings were a little over cooked. We have always ordered from Ficarellas and never had a problem, but this order was not the same as previous orders.