Market Street Pizza - Johnstown (NY)

5 /5 M Gdd: The pizza was FANTASTIC! I was in a pizza cinch at 9pm on a Saturday night. I ordered a large half cheese half pepperoni, peppers, onions. While I was picking it up at 9:15pm I ordered a cannoli and that was top notch as well. I ate that in my car on the way home. I recommend this place and I will definitely order again.

4 /5 Derrick Coon: Arguably the best pizza in Johnstown. Far better than Vince’s; but the big plexiglass with handing money with gloves was a bit strange when COVID isn’t a thing really anymore. The cash only sucks, but otherwise it’s a good spot for a pizza in town.

4 /5 Tania Avey Duffin: Cash only. No dine in. Pizza was great. Our teenagers thought it was the best pizza we had during our 2 week vacation through the Eastern USA (we had pizza 4 times.) Service was a little funny. Garlic knots were great. Place looked like a dive. Not busy at all for a Saturday evening. But again, the pizza was great.

5 /5 Floyd Eggleston: Awesome food every time! Pizza is delicious. I used to work here a long time ago & the food was great then & still is like I remember. The owners are kind & work really hard by themselves to make everything perfect. I have no complaints whatsoever and Ive been ordering once a week the past few weeks now. Their prices are very reasonable & Id recommend for anyone. Btw, you gotta try their house dressing, its creamy & perfect for dipping certain pizzas & sides.

5 /5 Daniel Donnelly: Certainly unique decorations, what with antique cameras, old posters, ten coin-operated vending machines, retro arcade game. Prices fair and the end product is delicious (two Sicilians with extra cheese)! Automatic Tell Machine on-site (this pizzeria is cash only!), and several tables for dining in. Friendly cashiers.