Sunset Grill - Ithaca (NY)

3 /5 Jack Stanick: Not a bad spot at all. Fair pricing, quality diner food. Decent location and nice staff. Steak and eggs were good and worth it; you get what you pay for. Would recommend for a Saturday or Sunday brunch.

3 /5 Angelo Garcia: Well at first I was very excited to visit this location, the view from the balcony is amazing but only available during the warmer months!Coffee was perfect so I thought the food would follow suit. Nope! The home fries were a bit dry , the eggs Benedict lacking sauce * not enough provided * so they sat on a dry English Muffin, the little sauce I got was tasteful. I ordered 2 pancakes, they looked good, not enough butter provided and if you wanted real Maple Syrup you pay $2.50 extra * should have been included in the price oh well! The gentleman who gave us a seat, young fellow, hardly spoke, mute? Shy? Who knows! No courtesy or manners? The waitress must have been having a hard day she also didn’t speak much! However the place still managed to bring a good crowd so they must be doing something right… right? Nevertheless I will not be coming back…

5 /5 RaeSharon Alonzo: This was an amazing place! The view alone was worth coming here. We all ordered different burgers and they were all devoured. Tater tots as an option as opposed to French fries was great, and an extra plus: the had garlic parmesean seasoned tots! (It was fresh garlic w oil, so as long as you dont mind a little extra grease, this is a must order!)

5 /5 Melissa Bolanos: Went up to Ithaca with family for the weekend and opted to dine local instead of going to another chain restaurant. This is a really cute spot overlooking Cayuga Lake with reasonably priced meals. Despite how busy it was, we were seated fairly quickly & Our waiter was very attentive and friendly. Definitely recommend!

5 /5 Phương Đài Trịnh: Sunset Grill is an exceptional spot in Ithaca that combines delicious food, stunning views, and a laid-back, welcoming atmosphere. Located in a prime location with views of the surrounding landscape, this restaurant is the perfect place to unwind, enjoy a great meal, and watch the sunset—hence the name! The menu at Sunset Grill offers a fantastic variety of dishes, with something to satisfy every palate. Their seafood specials are always fresh and flavorful, with the grilled salmon often being a crowd favorite. It’s perfectly seasoned and served with a side of roasted vegetables that complement the dish beautifully. For those who prefer meat, the steak and fries is a must-try—tender, juicy, and cooked to perfection. The pulled pork sandwich is another hit, offering a perfect balance of smoky, sweet, and savory flavors. In addition to the fantastic food, the Sunset Grill offers a solid selection of craft beers, cocktails, and wines, making it an ideal spot for a leisurely drink as well. The house margarita is a standout—refreshing with just the right amount of zing. They also serve up creative seasonal cocktails that change throughout the year, making it fun to visit and try something new. The atmosphere is relaxed and friendly, with both indoor and outdoor seating options, so you can take full advantage of the beautiful views. The staff is welcoming and attentive, always ensuring your experience is enjoyable. Whether you’re visiting for a casual dinner with friends or a special occasion, the vibe at Sunset Grill makes it a perfect spot to sit back, relax, and enjoy the moment. For anyone in Ithaca, Sunset Grill is the ideal place to enjoy fresh, flavorful food, amazing drinks, and breathtaking views. Whether youre there for a sunset dinner or a weekend brunch, it’s a place that never disappoints.