The Arch Restaurant - Brewster (NY)

5 /5 Latasha Fisher-Ruiz: I have never had french cuisine till dining here. My words would truly fall shorts for how outstanding the food tastes and the service is. So many attentive personnel. The atmosphere took you out of Brewster, New York and into a warm and peaceful far-off place. For my first experience myself, my husband, our kids and family members have been incredibly impressed. We will be returning, and I am eager to do so.

5 /5 Alp Ojalvo: My husband and I went to The Arch Restaurant for Valentines Day, and it was a lovely experience. The restaurant has an authentic, old-world charm, and the real fireplace added to the warm and intimate ambiance—perfect for a romantic evening. For the holiday, they offered a prix fixe three-course menu. I started with the Beef Carpaccio (black truffle aioli, crispy capers, pickled caviar, chili crunch, crispy garlic). While the flavors were nice, I found the slices a bit too thick—carpaccio is usually paper-thin for that melt-in-your-mouth experience. For my entrée, I had Coq au Vin, and it was outstanding! The chicken was braised beautifully, incredibly tender, and full of rich, well-balanced flavors. The vegetables and fingerling potatoes were perfectly cooked and complemented the dish wonderfully. Dessert was the highlight! I had the Cherry Sponge Cake (red wine cherry reduction, lemon-scented vanilla gelato), and it was absolutely divine. If I could, I would have ordered ten more! I really hope they make this a permanent menu item. The service was attentive, and overall, it was a very enjoyable evening. I look forward to coming back to try their regular menu. If youre looking for a cozy, elegant dining experience, The Arch is definitely worth a visit!

5 /5 Joshua Stone: What an improvement! This restaurant has been revamped and feels much nicer than before. The food was very good. Great service. Will definitely be back!

5 /5 Marian Belli: I attended Sunday Brunch. I started with polenta bites and had Croque madame as entree. Meal was outstanding. I was too sated to order dessert! Meal, service, and atmosphere were outstanding. Well worth the price! Also, a very romantic place!

5 /5 Anna Molly: My evening at The Arch Restaurant was fantastic. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt both refined and inviting — the fireplace in the dining room added a cozy, elegant touch that set the tone perfectly. The food and drinks were excellent: each course felt carefully crafted and full of flavour, and the cocktails were spot-on. The staff were genuinely caring and attentive without ever making us feel rushed — a great balance. Also appreciated the pricing: given the quality of the meal, the value was very good. I’ll definitely be coming back and would recommend this spot to anyone looking for a memorable fine-dining experience in a comfortable setting.