Tilly Foster Farm Museum - Brewster (NY)

5 /5 John Damiano: Went for my nieces wedding had an amazing time

5 /5 Anna Messina: * Mr. and Mrs. Jacob Homberg * My niece, Erin Shaughnessy, had the most beautiful wedding at Tilly Foster Farm. It was truly a magical day. The ceremony took place outdoors surrounded by the farms natural beauty. It felt like we stepped into a fairytale. The barn reception was warm and welcoming. Its wooden beams and cozy atmosphere made the evening feel both romantic and festive. The food was outstanding - fresh, flavorful, and plentiful. The staff was attentive, friendly, and made sure everything ran smoothly. You could see the joy on the faces of the Bride & Groom as they celebrated their love and gave all of us memories to treasure forever. Tilly Foster Farm is a gem for weddings - charming, inviting, and unforgettable.

5 /5 Dawn ORourke: We had our wedding at Tillys on September 2nd 2023. It was such an amazing experience! The staff was so lovely and helpful! The food was great! The venue itself is so beautiful! I wouldnt have changed a thing about that day! I highly recommend Tillys for a wedding! We were even able to take pictures with the animals!

2 /5 S. A.F.: Two of our party of three had been there before and had had good experiences, but this visit was disappointing. All three at our table are GF, so needed to menu guidance to avoid gluten. Unfortunately, while our servers were very pleasant and well-intentioned, they were neither knowledgeable nor well trained. After multiple back-and-forths to the kitchen with gluten questions, all three of us settled on the seared scallops. Dishes were poorly executed -- especially for the price point. The seared scallops were not so much seared as steamed. (My guess is that the pan was not hot enough to recover from the addition of three orders of scallops at once.) There were no GF desserts except for ice cream (yawn), so our birthday celebration ended with a shrug. This is a place with potential: the venue isnt bad, and the staff are eager to please. Not sure whether this was an off night, but wont rush back.