Tillys Diner - Monticello (NY)

4 /5 B.D. Y.: We stopped here on our way to Cooperstown, after flying in from Los Angeles, where there are very few diners. This is a great one. The menu has plenty of staples as well as more creative options.

4 /5 Hadi Shadkam: Stopped here for a quick lunch. The food was okay, but the service and vibre were better than the food.

5 /5 Adam Lorber: Being from Long Island, there is no shortage of diners. We came to the Catskills for a 3 day getaway. Tillys diner was one of the best highlights of our trip. We were staying at Resorts World but wanted to explore the area. This diner makes everything from scratch and has a great classic old diner feel. The servers were very friendly, the prices were great and quantity/quality of food is amazing. We ended up coming to Tillys 3 times over 3 days rather than eating at Resorts World. We highly recommend this diner.

3 /5 Rebecca Kaplan-Fisher: We stopped in for lunch today. Not very busy. He ordered the beef and lamb gyro and white bean soup, I ordered hot open roast beef. It took almost a half an hour to get lunch to the table, dont understand why there were only four other people in there. Wait staff was distant and unfriendly. Typical dining decor hasnt been updated in years. When we did get our food it was actually tasty, flavorful and good-sized portions. My husband asked for the ketchup for his french fries- she placed an open bottle of ketchup on the table. WILD. Prices are reasonable for the portions. My husband really enjoyed the white bean soup he said it was flavorful and tasty. He also said it was one of the better gyro he has eaten, the meat was flavorful and tender. Might stop in again, and try something for dinner one night.