Tonys Pizzeria - Herkimer (NY)

5 /5 Neil Kitty: In the middle of a roadtrip we stopped off strictly because the reviews were awesome. Man, so glad we did!! I got the chicken cesar salad and the garlic pizza. These portions lasted me for like 3 days!! Service was so attentive and they are experts at what they do. It was clean for the most part, but right before closing so I figured no biggie. The bathroom was very decent. Prices are reasonable and youre supporting a small business so why not. Will visit again when in the area!

5 /5 R H: While staying In Herkimer,NY for a night i decided to try this pizzeria on the advice of the desk clerk at my hotel and her advice was correct Tonys Pizzeria makes a great pizza and there garlic bread is very good also. The pizza is what i would call a thick crust but not pan style. I ordered a small pepperoni and sausage with extra cheese and an order of garlic bread. I got it to go, but the pizzeria looks like a great place to eat in at with plenty of seating. My pizza and bread took about 20 minutes, and It was ready to go back to the Red Roof Inn with me.

5 /5 Logan Valerio: The pizza here is great. Great sized slices with quality toppings. The people here are even better. After only a few stops in they remembered my name and my order. Always welcoming.

4 /5 Carlos Fernandez: Address in Yelp seems wrong but found via Google. Good thing we did because the pizza was very good. Crust was nice, thick but light and crunchy, a la Sicilian pan pizza but not square. Fresh veggies, sauce wasnt too sweet or heavy and ok cheese (maybe a little bland). Great little road trip find.

5 /5 Space Ghost: Visiting from Chicago. I ate here because it was SO HOT outside I didnt want to walk far from my hotel. It was unbelievably good. I tried a slice they had already sitting there and it was so good I ordered a whole pizza. I had an unusual pizza with hamburger,sausage,cherry tomatoes,jalepeno and a lot of ricotta cheese! Its among the best Ive ever had anywhere. Cool people working there too. The dining atmosphere is plain Jane and nothing to write home about, but most folks were just getting it to go. This is really really good!