new-york Date: 10-07-2025

List 19 Auto Services , Car Repair in Monticello, NY

NameAddress
1Auto Alignment World176 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
2Contrys Automotive Ii55 Foss Rd, Monticello, NY 12701
3Broadway Auto Service511 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
4Eddie Auto Repair100 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
5Robert Green Chevrolet Service236 Bridgeville Rd, Monticello, NY 12701
6Robert Green Auto and Truck236 Bridgeville Rd, Monticello, NY 12701
7Paveses Service Station36 E Cold Spring Rd, Monticello, NY 12701
852 Automotive76 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
9Monticello Auto Repair13 Liberty St, Monticello, NY 12701
10Kings Collision Service78 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
11Robert Green Chevrolet Sales, Service, & Parts236 Bridgeville Rd, Monticello, NY 12701
12Robert Green Mopar Express Service Lane178 Bridgeville Rd, Monticello, NY 12701
13Tire Discount Center176 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
14Maplewood Auto Service Center414 NY-17B, Monticello, NY 12701
15Sedlacks Auto Body Inc3520 NY-42, Monticello, NY 12701
16G & C Auto Repair Shop511 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
17AutoZone Auto Parts4386 NY-42, Monticello, NY 12701
18Old 17 Auto230 Old Rte 17, Monticello, NY 12701
19HIGH LEVEL AUTO BODY MECHANIC SHOP & TOWING SERVICES47 Coopers Corners Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

1.Auto Alignment World

Address: 176 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (9):

Brett Robbins Great company. Brought my truck in for a desperately needed alignment. I made an appointment, got there early and they took me right in. They did a great job at a great price.
5 /5
Joseph Kushner Couldnt get an alignment
3 /5

2.Contrys Automotive Ii

Address: 55 Foss Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

images Contrys Automotive Ii

Reviewed by the users (8):

Sandra Hall-Davis Highly recommend. Very knowledgeable and reasonable Excellent.
5 /5
Dennis Lamantia Just wondering why it takes all day to get a call back I called at 9am and then at 1130 I’m getting annoyed been getting the run around with these people smh
2 /5

3.Broadway Auto Service

Address: 511 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (70):

Megan Mckoy Just went here first person told me the job would cost 350. Walk to the bank to take out the cash. Come back when my car is done the original person is gone and someone else is there that is now charging me 450. So now I have to use my card because I dont have enough cash and end up paying 155 dollars more than what I was told Id be paying.
1 /5
Roberto Ramos They do a very good job. I am recommending.
5 /5

4.Eddie Auto Repair

Address: 100 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (67):

Paola Villaneda I brought my car there for a sensor repair. George and Eddie were terrific , they repaired only what needed to be repaired and was not charged for unnecessary repairs . They took care of me beyond my expectations . I highly recommend this shop , you will be satisfied with their service and prices. Thank you George and Eddie
5 /5
John Borba Eddie is a saint. Jeep broke down, late on Friday. Eddie stayed open, found the problem, got the parts, did the repair and I was on my way. I was charged a bargain price. Also, Eddie is a great guy, friendly and competent, a true pro. His young helper guy is also quite capable and does quick and good work. Eddies is exceptionable.
5 /5

5.Robert Green Chevrolet Service

Address: 236 Bridgeville Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

images Robert Green Chevrolet Service

Reviewed by the users (67):

Lindsey Minkus I have a 19 Traverse that has had a shudder issue for the last year and a half. I had brought it to the dealer I bought it from (in Middletown) multiple times over the last year and a half. The first time they did a transmission flush ( $450+ spent), the second time they blamed it on the evap valve & exhaust system ($800+ spent and was in the shop for 3 months, with no loaner), the third time they did another transmission flush, right before Christmas I may add ($450+ spent). After that point I was aggravated with this dealership and was told they would diagnose it for free if it happened again (happened the same day I pulled it off the lot,, when I went back they refused to diagnose it until I drove it 500 miles). I decided to get a second opinion and brought it to Robert Green. Let me tell you, I will never bring my vehicle to anyone else. I dropped it on a Saturday morning, before a holiday Monday, we test drove it and they explained the possible issues and told me they would call before any work was performed to give me pricing (which they were awesome about) . They called me Tuesday morning letting me know it was ready for pickup. I test drove it, and it ran brand new, no issues at all. I couldnt believe it, I decided to wait and drive a bit more and longer distances to ensure it was resolved. The staff at Robert Green are friendly, knowledgeable, and take their time to listen to your concerns. The service was super quick and the staff communicated with me throughout the process. I will never bring my vehicle back to the dealer I bought it from, Robert Green is the only place to bring your vehicle for any issue you may have-- and theyre affordable!!!
5 /5
Renee Francis My daughter brought my car for an oil change on Saturday morning. She sat there for 40 minutes just for me to see three days later that it was never done!!! The alert just came on my dashboard and I have no oil in my car as I’m driving my kids! This is exhausting to constantly have run ins with a company that I’ve invested in for over 10 years!!! My daughter bought her car this year as well and has had issues from the first day when her brand new car was overheating fresh off the lot. Chevrolet has become inconsistent, inconvenient and the lack of efficiency is unbelievable. How dangerous and careless to not do an oil change when that is all the car was brought in for. We have the receipt of the transaction and she was walked out by Ann Marie in the express lane. Now I have to bring my car into New Hampton as my meter is on RED!
1 /5

6.Robert Green Auto and Truck

Address: 236 Bridgeville Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

images Robert Green Auto and Truck

Reviewed by the users (61):

Denise Sperl Todd S was professional and courteous. Made a promise and kept it. I highly recommend Todd S when buying your next vehicle .
5 /5
Darren Chan Gary is professional, has extensive knowledge, was really quick to respond and is courteous. I find myself saying this in very rare occasion, Gary at Robert Green Auto made car buying experience nice and pleasant. I am very happy with mine. 100% recommend Gary and Robert Green Auto if you are searching for a vehicle.
5 /5

7.Paveses Service Station

Address: 36 E Cold Spring Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (54):

zeeisaman1 Loder We needed repairs on our vehicles and went looking for a reputable mechanic, so I stopped in and met John. Super nice and have continued to fix most any problems we have. John and Charlie are the BEST at what they do!
5 /5
P Lowry (Lowry) Everyone here is very nice and knowledgeable! Super easy to work with.
5 /5

8.52 Automotive

Address: 76 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

images 52 Automotive

Reviewed by the users (52):

Ysrald Merossaint Now "Kings Collision" - amazing service. Shawn works with the utmost care and always makes sure youre satisfied with his work. Highly recommended.
5 /5
Jerry Cohen They were very efficient dealing with my insurance company. No problems, great people
5 /5

9.Monticello Auto Repair

Address: 13 Liberty St, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (4):

Alexandra Hernandez I highly recommend! Fast and reasonably priced service.
5 /5
jay patterson They were able to finish my car on time but I didnt get my car cleaned ask promised! But overall they were nice and got my car running smooth again!
3 /5

10.Kings Collision Service

Address: 78 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

images Kings Collision Service

Reviewed by the users (4):

James Garcia I called kings collision after another driver failed to yield, totaling my vehicles front end. They helped me along the entire process and made a very complicated situation as simple as possible. I was extremely satisfied with the quality of work and turn around time. I would highly recommend this company.
5 /5
William Youhas The worst collision shop!!!! Very shady took 5 month to do the work. Did a very poor job barely made it drivable on the road. The paint work was horrendous!!!!! And sloppy all new parts had scratches in it or burnt the paint. Contact with them was the worse they wouldn’t answer after 15 times texting them. All the owner did was lie on his end saying he would make it right and in the end the best help was the tow truck that made miracles. I would never Recommend this shop to anybody. In the end i ended up paying 12 grand out of my pocket because this shop does not know how to work on vehicles properly!!!!!
1 /5

11.Robert Green Chevrolet Sales, Service, & Parts

Address: 236 Bridgeville Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (390):

Cheyenne Freiermuth Recently got my 2025 Chevy Equinox RS from here and I can’t recommend them enough! Tom is wonderful! He went above and beyond to help my father and I with the process, and was very kind, courteous, and knowledgeable!
5 /5
Jason Cole Could not be happier. Ive bought new, used, Dodge and Chevy. No matter what brand im buying the salespeople get better and better. Service and parts is amazing as well. 100% Make you feel like family. WONT GO ANYWHERE ELSE
5 /5

12.Robert Green Mopar Express Service Lane

Address: 178 Bridgeville Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (35):

Shaun Maloney Friendly staff, quick service and most affordable oil change Ive seen in a while. Definitely recommend going here.
5 /5
Daris Isbell Friendly and they do good work. However, they don’t take reservations and will turn you away if they are too busy (even if you show up an hour before they close). Recommend you arrive right when they open.
3 /5

13.Tire Discount Center

Address: 176 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (296):

Gina Roberts Last week while traveling I bought a cheap tire to replace a flat tire so I wouldnt have to drive home on donut tire that came with my car. I wanted to drive home safely with a spare tire. My family and I have been going here to get our tires for over 30 years. We just got new tires for the car 3 weeks ago. I wanted to replace that 1 tire to be like the other 3 tires. The waiting area is clean and has plenty of seating. The staff is friendly.
5 /5
Will Bachrach This place is super nice and professional! Really fast and talented, the team at Tire Discount found the puncture in my tire quickly and fixed it. They did not even charge me for their services! They only charge for larger fixes. Best tire store in Sullivan County!
5 /5

14.Maplewood Auto Service Center

Address: 414 NY-17B, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (28):

Dan Dickson Im surprised at the negative reviews. Ive been very pleased with this service center, originally under Tony and now managed by the new owner, Moe. My second car is an older Saturn that I am keeping alive for sentimental reasons and these guys have done amazing things to keep it on the road, always for a reasonable price. Granted, theyre sometimes busy and you may need to have some schedule flexibility, but IMHO thats a small price to pay for professional and honest service.
5 /5
Danny G Best guys in town excellent mechanics fair and honest
5 /5

15.Sedlacks Auto Body Inc

Address: 3520 NY-42, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (27):

Steven Mioglionico Bill and his team did an amazing job on my truck. Bill kept me up to date weekly on the progress of my repairs. I couldnt have asked for a better out come. I highly recommend Sedlacks auto body for any of your auto body needs.
5 /5
Paul Migliaccio Bill dosent play games, 100% legit. Tells you exactly how it’s going to be. He knows how to deal with the insurance claim adjusters. Also knows a lot of people in his industry which helps him have better access to parts and materials. His work is absolutely flawless. No decision no 2nd choice…. This guy actually cares, very rare these days. Sedlacks Auto Body, should be your first choice.
5 /5

16.G & C Auto Repair Shop

Address: 511 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (26):

Christopher Villarrubia Went to ask to get a tire mounted and balanced. Wheel wasn’t on the car. They brought it to the back as I watched the tech mount the tire, have you or putting it on then never balanced it. Handed me the wheel and said as long as the tire is in the correct spot it would be balanced. Didn’t even check. Even though the wheel had old weights in it from a previous balance. Then to find out the tool he used left scratches all over the wheel. Only gave 2 stars bc they were able to do it short notice. Definitely will not be returning.
2 /5
JOHN DeStefano These guys didnt even know how to rotate tires properly. Shady from the minute I walked in. I doubt they even changed my oil filter. Do yourself a favor find somewhere else to go. This place left a bad taste in my mouth. I would never go back. Freezing cold inside the office, no heat. Bunch of shady characters. None of whom looked like they had any idea what they were doing. If I wasnt in a pinch I would have never even attempted to use them. Wouldnt provide me a receipt. Only accepts cash. Since the day I had them touch my truck. Its been acting weird.
1 /5

17.AutoZone Auto Parts

Address: 4386 NY-42, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (242):

Christina Cellini I don’t even know where to start. We were on hour SEVEN of needing help when we finally got our car to AutoZone in Monticello. Darren and his manager were a bigger help than the guy our insurance company sent with “roadside assistance”- helpful hint: don’t ever let something with your battery happen on a Sunday!! The terminal post on our battery had come loose at some point and the acid was obviously spraying for quite awhile. As busy as the store was, they made sure we were helped along with everyone else who came in and with a smile on their faces the whole time. Darren helped us get a new battery in and off we went. Without going into too much detail, it was a saga i don’t want to EVER have again, but if we had to do it, this would be the place we’d start. Literally couldn’t have done it without you guys!!!
5 /5
boot98camp Excellent service, had what I needed, friendly and helpful staff. Clean store, well organized and nice selection.
5 /5

18.Old 17 Auto

Address: 230 Old Rte 17, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (23):

Jennifer Bass Went for an inspection. Got right in, really nice guy even offered to let my kid play with his guitar. Nice waiting area. Fast and affordable!
5 /5
Greg Gorb Needed a radiator and radiator fan replacement (and more) on very short notice. These guys were very professional, extremely helpful and got the job done in a day. Joe was constantly updating me over the phone and explaining in detail what they were doing. Pricing was fair borderline good deal. Very satisfied.
5 /5

19.HIGH LEVEL AUTO BODY MECHANIC SHOP & TOWING SERVICES

Address: 47 Coopers Corners Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

Reviewed by the users (23):

zachary hemendinger I would give 0 stars if that was an option. They are scammers and cat fishers. Me and my dad drove 2 1/2 hours for parts off a car in their lot. Facebook pictures had the car looking in good condition and all in tact. They told us all the parts we needed were there and in good condition. Those being the front drivers side fender and the hood. Well we drove all the way out there to see the car ripped apart and none of parts were in good condition. THE HOOD WASN’T EVEN ON CAR. Not even an apology for the waste of time and money to drive out there.
1 /5
Garik Gasparyan I recently had my car repaired at high level auto body shop, and I’m beyond impressed! The staff was professional, friendly, and kept me updated throughout the process. Their work was flawless—my car looks brand new! What stood out was their attention to detail, honesty, and fair pricing. No hidden fees, just quality service. If you need auto body repairs, High level auto body shop is the place to go. I’ll definitely be back if I ever need their services again!
5 /5

Ask more about Monticello, New York (FAQ)

Top 15 Budget-Friendly Restaurants Near You in Monticello, NY

Find the top 15 budget-friendly restaurants near you in Monticello, NY, ideal for cheap, tasty, and satisfying meals.1.Savory Sweet Eatery, 2.Memitos Tacos And Deli, 3.Nellys Sports Bar, 4.The Burning Munch, 5.Albella Restaurant, 6.Nellys Latin Restaurant, 7.Liberty Kosher Pizza a/k/a Liberty pizza on Broadway, 8.Lotus, 9.Boosur Meat & Deli of Monticello, 10.Rugelach Heimishe Bakery, 11.Starters American Eatery, 12.Giovannis, 13.Salt & Pepper the Kitchen, 14.Solaia, 15.Ciao Bella,

List 4 Churches Open Monday in Monticello, NY

List 4 Churches Open Monday in Monticello, NY, Churches for Every Denomination: 1.St Peters Church, 2.Love & Faith Church of God / Iglesia De Dios Amor y Fe, 3.Monticello Seventh Day Adventist Church, 4.The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints,

8 Recommended Insurance Agencies in Monticello, NY

8 Recommended Insurance Agencies in Monticello, NY: 1.Trust Insurance Agency NY, 2.Keats Insurance Agencies Inc dba Keats Agency, 3.Lawrence B Mler & Associates Inc, 4.Robert Wells - State Farm Insurance Agent, 5.Lawrence Miller Insurance Agency, 6.Harris Monti McLaughlin Insurance, 7.Merrell Benco Insurance Agency, 8.Paragon Insurance Agency,

Christmas 2026 Church Guide: Best 12 Churches Near You Monticello,NY

Looking for Christmas church services near Monticello,NY? Find recommended churches for Christmas 2026 and plan your holiday worship today.1.Calvary Church, 2.Restoration Church - monticello, 3.St Peters Church - monticello, 4.Monticello United Methodist Church, 5.St Johns Episcopal Church - monticello, 6.First Baptist Church - monticello, 7.Bethlehem Temple Church - monticello, 8.First Church of Monticello, Presbyterian, 9.Love & Faith Church of God / Iglesia De Dios Amor y Fe, 10.Monticello Seventh Day Adventist Church, 11.Shalom International Outreach Ministries Inc., 12.The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints - monticello,

Top Reviews 5 Nail Salons in Monticello, NY

Top 5 Reviews about Nail Salons in Monticello, Sullivan Country : 1.Amazing Threading Eyebrows Salon, 2.Angel Nails, 3.Rainbow Nails and Spa Salon, 4.Ivy Top Nails, 5.Da-Vi Nails,