5 /5 Allison Henry: My grandmother used to make Penuche fudge when I was a kid. It was always given to us as small gifts & we all looked forward to that every Christmas! Tin Bin Alley makes Penuche! First time I had ever seen it outside of my grandmother making it. I bought 4 different flavors of the fudge & they were all amazing! If you like old time things, cute, unique gifts & all sorts of fun stuff, this is the store for you! We purchased several different items, spoke to all of the employees-all great & took our time looking around! Will def visit again when in Cooperstown!