Keywords: insurance_agency,point_of_interest,establishment

Warren Insurance Agency - Ithaca (NY)

Address: 🏡 223 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850

Phone : +1 (607) 277-0267

Weekly Open time

Place GG: https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJCU-90guB0IkRmsYwzwyfcbQ

Where is Warren Insurance Agency 🏡?
223 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850
What is the phone number Warren Insurance Agency 📱?
(607) 277-0267
What Clients Are Saying about Warren Insurance Agency (on GG)

5 /5 Rob Hofstetter: Mr. Warren took the time to explain in great detail what I was actually purchasing. He offered me a different plan that was much cheaper than what I was considering. Jamie made the whole process seem so easy compared to my last agent. I have recommended him to my friends and family. Thank you Jamie and staff and may God Bless.

5 /5 ITOWN CREATIVE AGENCY: Many thanks to Jamie Warren for his help on our companys new policy. Jamie is easy to get in touch with and very direct in his planning. We highly recommend his office for business insurance.

5 /5 Tyler Hust: Erie Insurance is extremely highly rated and I’ve been very pleased with it. When I changed jobs and wanted to find an agent closer to my commute instead of 45 minutes the opposite direction, I reached out to Warren Insurance. Jamie Warren was professional and efficient and handled everything with ease. While I hope to never need to call in an emergency, I’m confident that he’d be able to handle any situation with diligence and efficiency.

5 /5 Tom Schlee: Wow, Warren Insurance reduced my combine Auto and Home Insurance almost in half! Great service, knowledgeable, and approachable. Amazing. Highly recommended.

1 /5 Alexander Niles: The woman I believe Kat was her name was very rude to me today when she answered the phone. My spouse and I had talked with the company many times that day and when I called the last time she was snotty about releasing information to me because technically my name wasnt kn the policy. I was very polite when asking and when spoken to this way I then said well ok my spouse is 2 feet from me il give her the phone. I mean come on Ive been on the phone with you 5 times today. Would not recommend unless of course you dont have to deal with Kat. Jamievwss always a delight to speak to tho.
Convenient Location
GG map: https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJCU-90guB0IkRmsYwzwyfcbQ

Others Near Ithaca,NY

10 Best Insurance Services in Ithaca, NY:Our Top 20 Picks

08-2025 Warren Insurance Agency in 10 Best Insurance Services in Ithaca, NY:Our Top 20 Picks

Nick Romo - State Farm Insurance Agent - Ithaca

Raymond Carruthers: We relocated from California to Upstate New York, moving 2 cars and buying 2houses. Nick and his team were very helpful in getting us through that transition. They worked to get us appropriate coverage which was tricky as we did a lot of building improvements. At the same time they improved our coverage they also helped us eliminate coverage that we didn’t need, saving us money. Besides being helpful and efficient, they were also upbeat and friendly. We recommend them highly if you are in need of insurance coverage.

Bailey Place Insurance - Ithaca

Doug Bentley: We have policies covering four vehicles and two residences. This week we were invited in to update some information so that we could look into the possibility of lowering our overall premium cost for all that coverage. Susie Dunn, our account manager was most courteous. And . . . we were treated to free coffee from Coffee Mania!

Zach Clark - State Farm Insurance Agent - Ithaca

Rich Rasmussen: It is no surprise that Zach Clark and his team were voted best insurance company in Ithaca and Tompkins county. Super knowledgeable, friendly, great attention to detail and incredibly helpful. Mark was my agent who helped with small business insurance and took his time to provide detailed answers to my questions. The rate was also amazing and super competitive. I highly recommend giving them a call for any of your insurance needs.

Nationwide Insurance: Anthony W Burchell - Ithaca

Mel Solomon: Burchell agency recently took over the Nationwide office in Ithaca after Stan Barlow retired. I am just getting to know the agents in the office. Recently without me contacting them, Nikki called me and said there may be new ratings that Nationwide has introduced for auto insurance and would I mind if she re-did a quote for me. In a few days I got a call from her saying that my premium would go down over $200 for 6 months. Could I use the $200? You bet! What agent would call a customer to voluntarily reduce pricing? A good agent, thats who. Thank you Nationwide insurance. And thank you Nikki and the Burchell agency.

Adam Megivern - State Farm Insurance Agent - Ithaca

Tiana P: I had an amazing experience working with Anthony for my auto insurance. From the start, he was incredibly knowledgeable and took the time to explain all my coverage options without any pressure. He helped me find a policy that not only fit my budget but also offered better coverage than what I had before. Communication was fast and clear—every question I had was answered right away. It’s rare to find someone who’s both professional and genuinely cares about their clients. I highly recommend Anthony D Henry to anyone looking for a trustworthy, responsive insurance agent!

State Farm: Lee Newhart Jr - Ithaca

Genesis Romero: Thank you to Nadine for her kindness and willingness to help!

Moscato & Associates Inc - Ithaca

Kirk Macolini: Barbara Brenner at Moscato & Associates helped me with my company’s health insurance for over a decade. Navigating health insurance for small businesses can be challenging and Barbara was always helpful. I found her competent, helpful, and she always seems to have my company and employees’ best interests in mind!

The Becker-Well Agency, Inc. - Ithaca

AMY LANZILOTTA: I have been using Becker-Wells since i began driving over 20 years ago. The ladies in the office have been wonderful and are always willing to check different carriers out for me and provide comparisons. I recall when I began driving, Linda set me up with a carrier until i had a couple years of driving under my belt. Then she signed me up with NYCM which has amazing rates. Very Happy!!!

Williams Insurance Agency - Trumansburg

Joseph Marrone: Always a pleasure working with Brenda at the Ovid office. She is very knowledgeable about various insurance products and helps me to select the best one to meet my needs. It is always a pleasant experience interacting with her.

Security Mutual Insurance Co - Ithaca

Gary Bennett: No responses to requests for held back recoverable funds although they were sent several emails, phone messages, and billing from contractor for additional repairs needed from storm damage.