new-york Date: 09-18-2025

Best 12 Diamond & Gold Jewelry Stores in Rochester, NY (part 3)

Jewelry StoresAddress
1Figgy Studio & Shop251 Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14607
2My Hoan Jewelry531 State St, Rochester, NY 14608
3Jared Jewelers300 Hylan Dr, Rochester, NY 14623
4Ridge Coin and Jewelry1085 East Ridge Road, Rochester, NY 14621
5Greece Gold Exchange2599 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14626
6Craft Company No.6785 University Ave, Rochester, NY 14607
7Palazzo Jewelers2851 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618
8KAY Jewelers232 Greece Ridge Center Dr Ste H-1, Rochester, NY 14626
9JF Jones Jewelers1588 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14615
10Pandora Jewelry3300 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618
11West Ridge Traders, Pawn, Fine Jewelry, Gold, Silver, Bullion & More1130 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14615
12The Source Fine Jewelers2147 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14626

1.Figgy Studio & Shop

Address: 251 Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14607

(279) user ratings total:

Geen Stagni It makes me sad to not be able to recommend Figgy, or at least the Studio/custom jewelry designing process, because the shop itself is gorgeous, well-maintained, and clearly supportive of local artists, which I also also believe in supporting. That being said, it does make me suspicious that Figgy doesn’t have a single review below 4* despite our experience, so here is ours: I went here with two of my best friends to make pieces to celebrate and commemorate my college graduation. They were having a walk-in design day so we were very happily accommodated on their second floor studio. The process does take 6ish weeks, we found out, so we had to get our jewelry shipped. The two ladies that explained the process and helped us create our pieces were wonderful and friendly, and we had a great time in the moment. However, fast forward to now when we actually receive our jewelry: we are very disappointed. We were told we could make “basically anything we wanted”, so one of my friends chose to make a “butterfly” shaped ring from a simple band, I chose to make a “class ring” from a leaf-like band, and my other friend chose to make a bracelet. We ran our ideas by the ladies and they told us they loved it, and would help us note everything down to how the stones are arranged to ensure they came out as we wanted. Unfortunately, they did not. They turned out terrible, in fact. My friend’s ring’s butterfly shape was not preserved, despite that being her main concern, and my ring turned out incredibly clunky and uneven. I have attached some photos of my intention vs result, as well as my friend’s ring (sorry for the bad quality, they are taken and tried on by my dad). As you can see, for my ring, the “leaves” were completely destroyed in the process. For my other friend’s bracelet, the stones were unevenly placed, and melded together poorly. This experience wasn’t cheap either, with our rings totaling around $160 and his bracelet almost $300. I respect the value of the artisan and am okay with the cost, but only if it had turned out as we expected. Now, I understand how the studio’s style might be different than what we were trying to design; however, I think I rightfully believe that it should have been the ladies’ duty to let us know if they don’t think our idea could be executed. And frankly, the quality of the execution just isn’t up to par with a professional, and I’m heartbroken as I can only graduate college once, and now I don’t have a class ring to show off.
2 /5

2.My Hoan Jewelry

Address: 531 State St, Rochester, NY 14608

(26) user ratings total:

Debra Gonzalez They are so sweet and have an extensive variety of gold jewelry; they have great selection of semi precious stones, amazing jewelry ❤️ Service is superb! They are#1 The owner was amazing and so helpful, he sized my new watch for just $5 I highly recommend them. My best wishes to them!!
5 /5

3.Jared Jewelers

Address: 300 Hylan Dr, Rochester, NY 14623

(251) user ratings total:

Ashley Moore I had to exchange a necklace that was ordered online, Katie was incredible with helping me return and repurchase the necklace. She also helped get me a refund and get me another welcome discount applied. Thank you Katie, you made the process easy and made it happen fast
5 /5

4.Ridge Coin and Jewelry

Address: 1085 East Ridge Road, Rochester, NY 14621

(238) user ratings total:

DeAnna Salamone Classy and professional, Best compensation for your Gold etc… in Rochester. Done business with them a handful of times now and also been to many places around the county. Very much appreciate them working with me, forgot my inventory sheet of items when I went to sell, after making the sale wasn’t sure everything was counted. Went back they were good to re evaluate and bumped up the price for me. They didn’t have to that’s excellent business practices.
5 /5

5.Greece Gold Exchange

Address: 2599 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14626

(233) user ratings total:

Josh Newman Im pretty new to Silver stacking and wanted a chance to develop a relationship with a local shop. Im glad I stopped in and purchased a few rounds today... These guys were very friendly, knowledgeable, and like-minded! Its cool being able to walk in and talk shop, and getting a fair deal. Nice to meet you guys today, Ill be a new regular!
5 /5

6.Craft Company No.6

Address: 785 University Ave, Rochester, NY 14607

(232) user ratings total:

Rob Gioia A unique place with unique gifts and artwork, etc. right here on University Ave. Located in the NOTA- Neighborhood of the Arts- Craft Co. No. 6 is a great place to shop, look around and get ideas for your abode or a gift for a special person. There are 2 floors of fantastic finds. Friendly, knowledgeable service from the staff there too. Check it out!
5 /5

7.Palazzo Jewelers

Address: 2851 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618

(222) user ratings total:

Adam Petote John was fantastic. Went in to get two watches resized and you can tell he is a true professional with many years of experience. Took his time to make sure I was happy with the fit and I was in and out quick. Definitely will be coming back for any other jewelery needs. Thanks John!
5 /5

8.KAY Jewelers

Address: 232 Greece Ridge Center Dr Ste H-1, Rochester, NY 14626

(210) user ratings total:

Diamond Ebanks I wanted to leave a positive review, but unfortunately, I cant. I entered the store hoping to get my watch replaced and also to purchase a new watch for someone else. However, I wasnt greeted at all. The employee behind the register saw me standing directly in front of him, yet he did not acknowledge my presence after looking directly up at me multiple times. I waited for a few minutes, unsure if he was busy, but he still didnt say a word or even offer a simple "Ill be with you shortly." Maybe a bad day who knows but as, a result, I decided to leave and do not plan to make my purchase there. Whoever was working on June 3, 2025, around 4 or 5 PM, please take note of this message.
1 /5

9.JF Jones Jewelers

Address: 1588 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14615

images JF Jones Jewelers

(201) user ratings total:

Ezela Tagliente JF Jones does AMAZING work!! She is officially my jeweler for life! Brittany and her team are one of a kind, I dont shop anywhere else now when it comes to quality jewelry. My husband and I met Brittany in 2018 shopping for engagement rings. She took one of his family rings and created a custom ring for me, and collaborated with my husband to use the surrounding diamonds for a surprise necklace given to me on our wedding day!! But that was just how we started our relationship with Brittany at JF Jones. Over the past years she has worked with us countless times on beautiful gifts and pieces. From delicate Ania Haie fashion jewelry to the anniversary gifts my husband and I now exchange, its great to know that shes ready to partner with us. The store has been around for almost 100 years, and everything is excellent quality! She has items for any price range! I also recently did her jewelry box clean out program - bring in broken or unwanted jewelry and she will value it and apply that value to your next purchase!!
5 /5

10.Pandora Jewelry

Address: 3300 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618

(2) user ratings total:

Pamela Wahls Staff was very helpful and attentive.
5 /5

11.West Ridge Traders, Pawn, Fine Jewelry, Gold, Silver, Bullion & More

Address: 1130 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14615

(196) user ratings total:

Latroy Pate Made a call today for some questions spoke to Joe and oh my I haven’t even entered the store yet but the over the phone customer service was phenomenal clear and extra elaborate details I gained a lot from the convo definitely recommend them
5 /5

12.The Source Fine Jewelers

Address: 2147 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14626

(1900) user ratings total:

Carol Cody We went in to have a ring cut off, I don’t recall the woman’s name who did that, but she was very nice. We also wanted to look at rings for our anniversary. Another salesperson, Linda helped us find a gorgeous anniversary band and my husband bought it for me. She was very kind and friendly and it made our experience even better.
5 /5