Columbus Public House - Sherburne (NY)

5 /5 Brian L: Good all around. Nice atmosphere and appearance. Small but what I would consider a popular menu. We ordered the special that was chicken and biscuits (with mashed potatoes) and the Philly cheesesteak. The Philly was very good, served on an excellent bun with a wicked cool custom grill stamp on top! Again, I really liked the presentation here. The house cut fries also had a very tasty seasoning. I would recommend bottled water if you want water. The tap has a very strong sulfer taste.

5 /5 Tim Mclaughlin: The food and service were very good! The wings are phenomenal. Tacos and cheese steak also delicious.

2 /5 Matthew Atcher: I ordered take out last night. We ordered two bowls of broccoli cheddar soup. Didn’t expect the container to be half full…when measured it was a half of a cup.

5 /5 Kali Walsh: If I could give 100 stars, I would!! Highly recommend for lunch / quick bite. My partner and I were on our way to the animal shelter near by, 2 hours away from home so we just stopped at really the first place we found on Google maps. And gosh, we wish we didnt live so far away!!! The atmosphere in this restaurant was so nice, very home like, relax, clean, organized. Just overall really great. We ended up sitting at the bar because we enjoy doing that. The waitstaff was literally amazing. We didnt catch either of their names but they were such wonderful people! Friendly, talkative. The waitress was seriously so sweet, kind, funny, friendly! And the food! Knock out of the park!!! The wings were seriously delicious, crispy, perfectly cooked, the sauces were AMAZING. The Cuban turkey club was SO good. So much flavor, juicy turkey. The steak & cheese sandwich was Perfect. Juicy steak, perfect amount of veggies to steak ratio. And I loved that it was on a hamburger sized roll instead of a giant sub roll. The handcut fries were a little more done to my personal liking but still, VERY good! Their pasta salad was super crisp, fresh and not overly drenched in dressing, such a good even pasta salad! We are absolutely coming back if were in the area again! Or, would maybe even make a special trip to come back out! HIGHLY recommend. I love that they have a smaller menu, too!

5 /5 Stephanie Crain: Their specials are amazing, have tried several sandwiches on regular menu, always delicious, porch is great to sit on, friendly staff, homemade desserts!