Rothmanns Steakhouse - East Norwich (NY)

4 /5 Nafsika Corfu: Had our New Years Lunch with the family. We had the whole place to ourselves when we arrived but it soon filled up. We had several darters and Porterhouse Steak for the main course. One had the Hampton roll. The ambiance was lovely as it was not busy and the waiters were very attentive to us.

4 /5 Nelly Lin: Great place to relax and have a premium dinner w friends, family or business purpose. Numerous amounts of selections! Ordered filet mignon medium well which was good but better as medium rare. Truffle fries were good but not strongly recommended.

2 /5 Mr T: I personally liked this place, however someone sadly got sick who was in my party last night with food poisoning with sushi, and the food could have had better flavor, it was also a little pricy, 100$ for a bone in ribeye which looked 14 ounces. But the service was good and the place looked nice. If the person didn’t get sick I would give 4/5 stars but I do have to dock significantly since I’ve known these people for decades and they never get sick from food.

3 /5 Jetlagged Travelers: The service was great and the people were great but the steaks were all over cooked for all of us and when you get anything cooked to a medium or above, overcooked is not a good thing and will ruin the experience of the meat. The apps were all pretty good. The ambience is fantastic and the place is quite large. The quality of the steaks is hard to tell bc ours was too well done. I would give them another shot bc the ambiance and service was good, but Idk, should I?

5 /5 Robert Torossian: Rothmann’s is a classic Long Island steakhouse done right. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere feels upscale but comfortable—perfect for a special occasion or a great night out. The steaks are outstanding: perfectly cooked, well-seasoned, and high quality. The sides are just as memorable (the creamed spinach and potatoes are must-haves), and the portions are generous. Everything comes out hot and timed well. Service was attentive, professional, and knowledgeable without being overbearing. You really feel taken care of from start to finish. The wine list is extensive and pairs beautifully with the menu. Consistently excellent food, service, and ambiance. A true staple for anyone looking for a top-tier steakhouse experience on Long Island. Highly recommend.