New York Pizzeria - New Berlin (NY)

5 /5 Dayna Miller: We had a dinner party and ordered NYP, I’m so grateful for how easy it was to place my order—the whole process was smooth and stress-free! Everyone couldn’t stop talking about how delicious the food was. Thank you for making it such a great experience from start to finish!

5 /5 MxShawn42: this place was packed! and that says alot! great food and people! cant wait to get back to new york for some more good eats!

5 /5 Ty S: We were staying in Edmeston for a quick birthday getaway and accidentally placed our pizza order through DoorDash at the wrong location. When we arrived at the New Berlin restaurant, we were greeted warmly and kindly informed of the mix-up. Without hesitation, they offered to remake our order on the spot. The owner even handed us a fresh pizza that had just come out of the oven so we didn’t have to wait such an unexpected and generous gesture. And it was delicious! What started as my mistake turned into a friendly encounter and a truly memorable experience. Thank you again for the exceptional hospitality!

5 /5 Jennifer Noble: New York Pizzeria is always topnotch!! Food and service are always amazing! Love the subrolls they now sell as a 6-pack. The wine offered is very good as well as inexpensive! We are always greeted with a friendly face and a smile. While many restaurants have increased their prices, NYP prices seem to be the same. They truly care about their customers and community. If you have never been or haven’t been in a while, I strongly recommend you visit. You will not be disappointed!

5 /5 Nancy Palmer: It was recommended to visit New York Pizzeria when I was recently in New Berlin with a friend on vacation and am very glad we did! This pizza was the best I’ve ever had and only wish I could have brought many pizzas back home with me to Cincinnati (great place for a second location btw!). :) The atmosphere was great as well as the staff. We also overheard someone at the table behind us say their pizza was the best they’ve ever had! Loved everything about it.