Nonnalisas - Plattsburgh (NY)

5 /5 Jawana Watson Silvestri: Updated review 05/31/25. We were finally able to eat here and man was it worth it! The food is authentic, scratch, home cooked meals and cooked to order. It is a traditional italian feast. Be prepared to wait because it isnt fast food. The owner does the cooking! Music playing was traditional italian folk music. Prices are good, server was awesome. If you want an authentic Italian experience, this is your place! I have stopped by here twice when they were supposed to be open and they were closed. I will call before I make a trip over there again.

5 /5 Iris Duggan: We went here with a group of 6 on Easter. It was absolutely amazing. We had been driving all day, the food was delicious and the servers were so friendly and accommodating. The wait time was pretty long because they cook everything there from scratch, but it was definitely worth it. They made GF pasta on request and they were super considerate of allergens. Our server was so so nice and the whole atmosphere was great. Would totally recommend.

5 /5 Marcella Henry: The food here is amazing! They cook it all from scratch so dont expect super fast food!! Like the menu says, enjoy the wait! Youll be glad you did!! I had the Seafood Alfredo and actually got shivers when I took the first bite! It was so good! The shrimp were huge and there were dozens of scallops! It is a small place at the end of a strip mall type building. They only take cash or checks but there is an ATM machine inside. And let me tell you the food is worth it! I cant wait to go back and try their Lasagna which is one of their most popular dishes. Went back again and had the Lasagna it was HUGE and also had the lemon cake with raspberry topping to go. So flavorful and delicious! Been back several times, this time I tried The Don, sautéed mushrooms were so delicious I could just eat those as a side dish! Grilled chicken over Alfredo sauce and noodles. A few weeks ago I took a friend and she had the chicken Parmesan sandwich, it was huge and she said it was the best she ever had.

5 /5 Sarah Burden: Everything was so amazing!! Nonna Lisa is the best! We were so lucky to have found such a gem! Make sure you make time because the cooking is fresh and delicious!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️

5 /5 Shawn Riley: We were visiting Platsburg from Albany NY and stop at Nonnalisas for dinner. So glad we stopped here. The food is amazing with big portions. My wife got the Egg Plant parm and it was excellent. I got the chicken marsala and that was also amazing. Cooked to perfection. If this place was up on the main road and not in the back of a strip mall I dont know how they would keep up with the customers. Its a hidden gem. The women that took our order was a sweetheart. We will definitely be stopping in our next time we are up their. Oh almost forgot we got taramisu to go and that was the icing on the cake. Amazing. This place reminds me of home cooking. Much better then your chain restaurants.