Old City Hall Brewery - Oswego (NY)

5 /5 David Murray: We stopped in on a late Sunday afternoon. There was plenty of convenient parking. We were seated immediately. Our waiter, Alex, was attentive & polite. We wanted to relax and sample a few drinks before ordering, and that was not a problem. When we did order, our food was ready in a short time. The beers we had were good. I very much enjoyed everything we sampled. The food was also very good, and well presented. Whatever bad experiences other reviewers may have had have certainly been addressed. It was too cold for us to sit outside, but the outdoor area looks very nice as well. This would be a wonderful venue to relax with friends on a warmer day or evening.

2 /5 Heidi St. Louis: Had a reservation for 7:00, immediately got seated, which was great. The restaurant didnt seem terribly busy. Waited an hour and 35 minutes for our food.The waitress was inattentive. Two of our orders were messed up. If you order a house salad, be aware that the dressing on it is very herb-heavy and spicy. I ordered ranch dressing, but I got the house dressing. I decided to try it. Dont, especially if youre typically a ranch person. We waited nearly 20 minutes after we finished eating just for the waitress to bring us the check so we could leave. The main course food was decent, the portion of Mac and cheese was huge, but the long wait, infrequent communication and then the messed up order on top of that. Told the waitress I had a pork and GINGER allergy, she wrote down pork and garlic.. Yikes. Luckily nothing I ordered had ginger in it but if they think it was a garlic allergy the house dressing is concerning

5 /5 Theresa Adams: Absolutely beautiful, charming, restaurant and brewery! The owners have kept the charm of the history of the building and aesthetic while making the restaurant and bar updated and stunning. The beer was top notch with plenty of different styles to appeal to any craft beer lover. The menu offers great options with the ability to customize your meal with lots of variety for toppings/sides. Wish it weren’t so far from where I live or this would certainly be my new favorite place to relax and dine. Definitely worth visiting, and staying! I shall return!

5 /5 Anthony: Good Food and friendly service can’t ask for much more. Would like a bigger menu. I was surprised to see not many creative dishes on the menu like pasta or steaks or none fried seafood. Great location and nice setting deserves a more advanced menu.

5 /5 Tammy Trantham: Very nice old brewery. Service was great and their beer was wonderful. We stopped for lunch and it was perfect. Burger was delicious and fries were seasoned well. They had a great sour beer when I was there.