Old Fashioned Sub Shop - (NY)

4 /5 Lersch Holger (fahrbier): Subs are delicious. I like them almost as much as those on Main Street. Aunt ... I forgot. Paid $12 for a medium sized and a soda.

5 /5 Guldenschuh Conner (The_Schuhs): Absolutely incredible subs. A little on the expensive side, but other than Aunt Cookies, this is the best subs you can get in Geneseo. The employees are very nice as well!

5 /5 Spring Teeter: This is located inside Wegmans in Geneseo. The subs are great!!!! They are $15 which to me is a bit much, but everything is these days.

2 /5 redjacketish: This sub shop had gone downhill. There can be 5 people behind the counter yet the line of customers stretches into the next room. They were out of onions one day. ONIONS. They are a supermarket with an award winning produce section. They couldnt walk over to produce, grab a few onions, and slice them up? The most concerning thing however, is thier little gluten free area. It has separate sub papers and knives, but Ive seen both used for regular sub rolls. If you gluten intolerant, be aware.

3 /5 Greg Wheeler: Had a meatball sub. It was ok, not bad but not great. Tables really needed to be wiped. Staff did the bare minimum. Not what Id expect from something associated with Wegmans but it served the purpose.