Vesuvio Pizza. - Catskill (NY)

5 /5 Ginger Tatarzewski: Went here with my family. Everyone ordered a variety of food from pizza to eggplant parm to different types of wraps. The food was GREAT! Portions were very large, and the service was friendly. Prices were moderate. The owner was there and chatted with us - making sure everything was OK. All around great place for great food and great prices!!!

5 /5 Dezzi Bobezzi: Me and my mom absolutely LOVE this place!! They have the best pizza, kind staff, and inside is air conditioned. They can also be very creative with some of their pizzas, or atleast I think- I’ve never heard of lasagna pizza before but it was so yummy. The Italian subs are also to die for. And they also have cupping pepperonis, which are my absolute favorite and I can never find a pizza place that offers those anymore. 5/5 stars!⭐️☺️

1 /5 M C: I ordered a Margherita pizza, a chicken-bacon-cheese sandwich, fried dough, and curly fries through DoorDash. Everything was awful. The fries were fried so hard they were almost inedible, either stale, forgotten in the fryer, or just deliberately overcooked. The chicken cutlet in the sandwich was paper-thin, barely there, and completely flavorless, with no lettuce, tomato, or mayo as described on the menu. The bacon tasted like pre-packaged Oscar Mayer strips, not freshly cooked. The pizza was bland and forgettable. The fried dough for dessert was overcooked to the point of being rock-hard, clearly not fresh. I understand delivery takes time (mine was about 15–20 minutes), but this wasn’t a “sat too long” problem—it was a “bad from the start” problem. I don’t understand how this place has good reviews unless people simply don’t know good food. I expected better quality, but what I got was some of the worst takeout I’ve ever had. Whether this was just one bad cook or a reflection of how the restaurant operates, I’ll never be ordering from here again.

5 /5 Ken Post: We just stopped at Vesuvio Pizza for the first time, after driving by countless times. We cannot begin to express how glad we are that we stopped. This place is absolutely amazing, starting with the very friendly greeting and help from Nino. Our pizza slices? My Sicilian slice was the very best that I’ve ever had. There’s not even a close second. Ditto for my wife. She had a slice of white pizza with broccoli. She says it was by far the best she ever had and that’s saying something, coming from an Italian family that owned an Italian Restaurant for many years when she was younger. Cannot wait to come back here. Thank you Vesuvio and thank you, Nino!

5 /5 Breonna Dragon: Today was my boyfriend’s birthday and his family hosted his dinner at Vesuvio’s. The waitress Kourtney made sure to push the tables together for our party of 11, she made sure we had everything we needed from ketchup, forks, extra plates, etc. She was super attentive, she got all of our orders correct, the food came out within 10 minutes, she was super polite and we even brought our own cake in! I highly recommend Vesuvio’s not only for the food but the hospitality as well! Thank you for making this day a little extra special for him and his family!