Best 12 Auto Repair Shops Near near Me in Herkimer, NY (Update 2025)

Kenneth Sweeney I have been going to Skinners service garage for about 2 and 1/2 years now. And Ive always gotten excellent service and the staff are very courteous and will answer any questions you have and make good decisions if you cant make. Their workmanship is good and they will tell you exactly what needs to be done after they have inspected your vehicle for the issues you were bringing it there for and give you options on what you want to do. Another thing I like is the fact that you can bring your own parts and they will install them for you. The waiting room is just like sitting in your own living room which is very good and relaxing. I highly recommend Skinners to anyone thats looking for quality service .

Wayne Wilson The thought of buying a "new" vehicle was daunting and we were not looking forward to a hassle, but my father recommended Skinner, so we thought wed check it out. Not only did we find the vehicle we were looking for, but the staff was so helpful and not one person tried to pressure us into anything. They genuinely wanted to help is get what we needed. They made the process so easy, and they took care of EVERYTHING! We just picked it up! They even helped us out with some "extras" after the sale! Definitely add this place to your car shopping list!

ROBERT SMITH We have used Skinners for many years and have always been pleased with the service. The staff is always friendly and helpful. Its a pleasure doing business with them. The rates are reasonable and the workers are knowledgeable which we value a lot. When we go there with a problem we feel confident it will be handled right. As they work on your vehicle you are kept up to date as how they are progressing or if they ran into a problem, how it can be solved. It is also nice to be informed of upcoming inspections and how your vehicle is doing as far as wear & tear on your brakes, tires & other maintenance issues. It is nice to have a place to go where you can have your vehicle fixed and you know they are trustworthy and reliable.

Jessica LaFountain B&B Auto holds a special place in my heart. My Dad worked there for many years, mostly during my childhood. Brad is an amazing person who my Dad cherished up until the day he passed away. Even after his passing, I was still able to pop in and talk to Brad about my car is need be. I want to thank Brad for allowing my Dad to be a part of your business and for being a great friend to him all those years. Theres no better place to go!

Walter Plate I just had my old lexus for a misaligned steering wheel and the guy who attend me was super nice, everyone was very kind and even chat a bit. Definitely going back and make business with them.

Patrick Malowski My whole family has been going to Brad at B&B for years. Hes an honest person who will give the truth about your car. Its nerve-racking finding someone to work on your vehicle. Thank goodness weve had Brad all these years. Id highly recommend B&B to anyone.

Larry B I have an F350 Diesel and it was in need of an oil change. We live in our RV full time and the mechanic said he would give the truck a good review of key areas to ensure we werent going to have any surprise repairs. He found out that the front disc brakes were almost metal on metal and showed me there was hardly any brake pad left. I was extremely pleased how he was able to get the parts on a Sunday afternoon and still continue the work. He was able to get both the oil change and the front pads replaced surprisingly quickly. The bill was also very reasonable. Ask for the gentleman who has a beard and drives a 1994 Ford F350. :) He is very good and personable and best of all will do his best to get it done right.

Yasmina R Stopped by today for an oil change. Everything went smoothly. Mike was very professional over the phone with me and also in person. I got a good price with no tricks or hidden fees and would definely recommend them to anyone. My sister actually recommended them to me after she went in to get her car inspected. 10/10

Mary A Maybe the owner, "Rueben" needs to know his mechanics spent HOURS on June 14, 2025 outside, spewing hate, videotaping, playing loud music, and yelling at a rally being held across the highway from the garage!! Ignoring repairs to the vehicles there, to scream and yell at those people, while no work got done inside! What kind of place operates/tolerates this garbage when paying customers are waiting?

Kody Lupori Made an appropriate online because this was the only location that had availability on short notice. Drive 45 mins to the shop only to walk in and be told that they can do the oils change unless there are 2 people in the shop and in person just went to lunch. When they come back the other person is going to lunch. I then asked if I could come back in 2 hours only to be told no that they they would be closed!!!! Meanwhile closing is listed as 7pm and it’s 3:30. Something is systematically wrong here and if this is the business then they should just close or reduce hours until they can handle the basic auto works offered.

Kristen Hatcher Joseph and Steven were professional and patient. Gave us great advice and made us smile while we dealt with a tire emergency on a long-distance trip. Very grateful for their help.

Helen Saranzak My sister and I were traveling through the state and got a screw in our tire. We rolled into the Walmart tire center 15 minutes before closing. Larry and his coworker were very nice and checked out the car. Turns out that we needed a new tire and they were kind enough to install it even though they were ready to go home. I do appreciate their kindness and professionalism.

Guy Devitt This is the best auto body shop ever. Marty is an outstanding person, and he does top quality work. Thank you very much, Marty!

David Wallace Excellent work ðecades of experience award winning quality

Paul James Hit a deer and didn’t have the right insurance but they were able to work within my budget and make my car look new again

Denise Cavanaugh My experience at Tallman’s in Herkimer was excellent. They were professional and quick and very complimentary of my vehicle and the way I maintain it. I am very much of a car person and very specific with my cars and I was treated with respect… not always the case for a woman in this situation! But, well done Tallman’s!!!

Hetty Frye The fine gentlemen at Tallmans have always treated me with respect and been through with my vehicle. Often times not charging for services rendered. I’ve always had good experiences here. I’m glad I can find a trustworthy mechanic so close to home.

Kristina Maley Excellent service! They were quick, timely, and treated me like family. I truly appreciate their honest advice and the way they go above and beyond to ensure every customer feels well taken care of. Highly recommended!

carol wright I can not say enough great things about Joseph at Licari!!!! He went above and BEYOND for me!! I traded in a Porsche Cayenne for a beautiful Ford Bronco big bend they had. I’ve had my previous vehicle ( Porsche ) for almost 3 years , and I’ve had a better experience with Joe that I just met , than dealing with Porsche in Syracuse for 3 years. This is what customer service should be like !!! I’ve never in my life met a better car salesman than Joe. And I’ve had Luxury vehicles. Those luxury experiences DID NOT compare to how KIND, efficient, and helpful Joe is!! He knew how bad I wanted this vehicle , and HE MADE IT HAPPEN for me!!!! I am sending EVERYONE I know that’s looking for a new vehicle to Joe!!!! Thank you Joe!!!!

tractornut73 Jeff V and Joe went above and beyond to assist me in the purchase of 2023 Gmc Sierra elevation. It was a easy low pressure buying experience. Service after the sale was equally effortless and exceeded expectations

Tami Rolchigo I had the best experience at Licari Motor Car. I walked in there not sure what i wanted or what i could afford. Jeff Velardi was great to work with. He was patient, & so helpful. After driving 5 cars we finally found the perfect Jeep Grand Cherokee L and i was able to leave with it the same day. They made it so easy by doing all the work from DMV, insurance & the finances. By the time i was leaven i felt like family, i would recommend them to any one who needs a new vehicle. Thank you again Jeff & Joe for the amazing experience.

kelly alexander (xXSwear2GawdXx) Car stalled out along Route 90 over an hour from home and got off at the next exit. Thankfully my car was able to be checked with seconds of me pulling up. While he wasnt able to fix the problem, he gave me all the information I needed. Very grateful for his time and service.

Robert Reid Doolittle auto had me up and running within an hour, traveling to Nebraska with a loaded trailer at a flat and electrical problem on the trailer. They had me fixed up and moving. In no time got me in the same day. No problem compared to other locations in this town. Who couldn’t get to me till the next day, even though they weren’t busy I recommend these guys to everyone passing through

Nichole Brown Doolittles Auto Service station is top notch! Ive been going to them for the past year for variety of simple fixes and bigger jobs and they are always very professional, courteous, fast and do great work! I love that they are available at moments notice at times, evenings and weekends when most other places are closed and very cost efficient and dont over charge. Im a single mom with 3 teens and it means so much to have a great mechanic I can always count on to help me out! Thanks again to Mike and his family!!

Brian Markey Brad is a great guy, easy to work with on any type of tire youre looking for. Highly recommend.

David S Excellent! Talk to Brad... hell get you the tire when others cant. He knows what hes doing! If you want quick and honest service, You must try this place out, plain and simple!

Samantha Mosher Absolutely phenomenal! We had to get the snow tires on the truck asap because of the sudden change in weather and storms coming. I called countless shops in the area and everyone was completely booked or just wouldn’t answer the phone in general. I called Keblish and I didn’t even have to make an appointment. You just pull up and wait your turn. From when we pulled up and got the tires changed it took 45mins MAX. It was a great operation. Fast, high quality, and cheap work. I will absolutely be going there again and again.

Pat Wright My service experience was great. I dropped off my car, and was given a ride back home. A few hours later, I received a call that I was all set and my car was ready. I picked up my car, coupons wee applied and my oil change was done. They also checked on the tires, the parking brake ( which I requested) and the brakes, fluids, etc. I am happy with my first visit after purchasing my 2023 Chevy Traverse.

Annie Schell Oil change, tire rotation and puddle lamp replacement on a mirror. In and out in an hour and a half. The service staff is always friendly and efficient!

Ben Vennero Was just in for routine service on my 24 Trailblazer. Staff and service personnel were courteous and attentive as usual.

Aisha Brianne Super reliable! I initially used this business for new tires on my car and new brakes. I was very pleased with how quick and professional they were. I then used this business again to replace something covered under my factory warranty and a window repair. I definitely recommend and will be using Mohawk Motors again in the future.

aaron velardi My truck was in serious need of repairs. I heard the add for Mohawk Motors and thought I would give them a shot. I called on Thursday and was able to drop it off Monday. I had the truck back Thursday afternoon. After driving it for almost a week I can say they repaired everything the truck needed to get it back to like new! Jimmy the owner took great care of me and is all around nice guy. I will def go back!

Jaquays Brando (Branden) Excellent customer service, trustworthy and professional. Good people thank you

Gino Geruntino Fast work, good prices, and hometown service. Great place!

Clines Mind This place has uneducated people working here. I purchased a gift certificate for my son to take his car for an oil change. He knows nothing about oil changes since hes a new driver. So I figured Id save him the confusion and buy a gift certificate for the lowest priced oil change. The garage knew the exact make and model of his car. So it was determined on what kind of oil he was going to need. He took the gift certificate and the receipt with all the details to this place a few hours later. As soon as my son handed them the receipt and gift certificate, they asked him if he wanted full synthetic. My son, not knowing what that even means, said yes. Oil change was done, and the cashier is asking for more money. My son then calls me to tell me they want more money. So he hands the phone to the cashier. I then had to explain to him that I specifically purchased the gift certificate with the exact service in the description on the receipt and there was no need to try to upsell to someone that has no idea what the difference is in oils. He expected me to pay more over the phone, for which i refused. He then made my son wait even longer by removing the synthetic blend that he just put in, just so he could give him the oil that I paid for in the first place, which is the standard oil. Im not sure where they find such incompetent people. I will never use this place again for anything.

Asha Bonavita Great service. Jimmy was very friendly and kept us updated step by step through the entire process. He asked us about the specifics and ensured we were serviced accordingly. 10/10 recommend