Best 13 Jewelry Stores Near You Brooklyn, NY

Brendan G I recently had a custom chain and pendant made at Nu Castle Jewelers, and the experience was outstanding. The staff, especially, Sean and Andy took the time to really listen to my ideas and helped me refine the design into something even better than I imagined. The craftsmanship is incredible—every detail on the pendant is sharp and clean, and the chain feels solid and high quality. They kept me updated throughout the process, which made me feel confident in my purchase. The final piece is unique, personal, and something I’ll treasure for years. I highly recommend this store to anyone looking for custom jewelry that’s both beautiful and well made. I found them on TikTok, and I’m really glad I did. Highly recommended!!

Mario Argote If you are looking for a jewelry store that offers great prices and excellent customer service then Glitz is your place. In addition to a first-class selection of jewelry and watches, Glitz offers fairly priced repair services as well. In this age of impersonal big-box stores, Eddie, Glitzs owner, offers customers a personal touch that is hard to find anywhere else. So go and check out Glitzs beautiful merchandise and stay a while to chat with Eddie, who is always fun to talk to. Park Slope is lucky to have such a gem in its midst.

Athena Rain Romano I went there to have an engagement & wedding ring sized yesterday, and I was blown away by how kind the owners were to me. It is rare to find an honest jewelry store. I went in there for something simple and I was treated like I was making a huge purchase. They didn’t care about the money they just wanted to do the right thing by me, and they did. I will now buy every piece of jewelry here for the rest of time. I never write reviews, but I had such an amazing experience I had to share. I’ll be back next week to buy my future sister in law a gift. This is a family business with amazing, integrity filled people running it. Love them.

Asha Harvey Shout out to Kestrel and the whole Fitzgerald team. Thank you for playing such a big part in our wedding. Thank you for helping to make my wedding band and bridal necklace dreams come true! As a sustainability consultant and designer, I truly appreciated how collaborative the team was throughout. They were open to reusing heirlooms and recycling materials which I love. Perfect blend of old and new!

Gila Dayan Best store and best customer service!! They were extremely efficient and nice. Best unique pieces!! Highly recommend. I got my baby’s first bracelet from here and the quality is perfect. So happy!

Lennox Boston Excellent experience, he made sure I was good and even gave me advise for the Rolex I wanted. Highly recommended and would use him as one of those spots I go to to compare prices and he’s real honest.

Neena Yoon My boyfriend got me these for my birthday and they are STUNNING! The packaging is luxe and it also comes with the lab diamond certificate. The quality is as good as you’d expect from solid gold and lab grown diamonds. These are the most beautiful pair of earrings. I just want to stare at these all day. Customer service chat is also very prompt, kind, and responsive.

Zach Buckner If we could give Goldpoint 15 out of 10 stars, we would. Sue and Olivia are talented, friendly, inventive jewelers and people. When it comes to your wedding rings, you want a partner that really gets you and your vision. That’s Goldpoint through and through. Sue and Olivia are masters at everything they do, and created the most gorgeous, personal rings imaginable. They’re so easy to work with, and keep you involved in the process. From the early talks to the 3D renders to the wax model and finally to all the specific design choices you want to make, they’re just the best. We can’t tell you how many people have complimented our rings and commented on how much they reflect us and our tastes. If you’re considering working with Goldpoint, I’d stop considering and make the call.

Elmira Cheremisova Very poor customer service I purchased a piece of jewelry using the coupon sent me by the GF store. The website accepted the coupon and transaction went through. I did an actual purchase, not the “attempt”. My order was cancelled without any notification and money was paid. Nobody contacted me about refund until I contacted the store. I’ve been a regular customer but will never purchase from them again. You call your own store coupon a fraud attempt now? You send me a discount coupon and now publicly accusing me in fraud attempt? SHAME.

Merlin Mathew I want to shout out SA Vanessa! We had been to Brilliant Earth twice, a few months apart. Vanessa helped us both times and actually remembered us from our first meeting! She went above and beyond to help us figure out what we wanted and really cared about us leaving more informed and confident about the decisions we made. Thanks again Vanessa!

Rachel L Got an amazing deal on the Movado watch and this store is amazing with service, prices and inventory, feel confident stop by check them out! Al is a trustworthy person who knows his inventory well. He is kind and has nice things for all budgets..

Olivia Fonti Pages pieces are super unique, fun, and elevated. Picking out an engagement ring was my first dive into non-costume jewelry and it was at first a bit daunting. But Im absolutely obsessed with my ring, and my partner feels the same about his wedding band that we got from here. The whole experience was made infinitely better by working with Reese to select these pieces - Reese greeted us with joy, kindness, and patience each time wed walk in, and always shared thoughtful insight as we navigated through the jewelry on display. This has become a special place for us to and we will be back.

Kathy Barrett Michael and his staff are the best. I’ve been buying from Joan’s Gifts on 5th Ave for years. What a pleasure to get their advice and recommendations from someone who is like family. Thank you Michael and Harry and everyone else that work there.