Atlantic Grill - New York (NY)

5 /5 BrianKaren Johnson: We sat at the bar and had an incredible experience. The sushi was fresh and delicious, and our bartender, Gonzolo, made the night even better with great conversation and perfect recommendations. The vibe is relaxed yet upscale — ideal for a casual dinner or pre-show stop. And don’t miss the stunning Vhils portrait of Abraham Lincoln — it’s a breathtaking piece of art that makes this spot even more memorable. Highly recommend grabbing a seat at the bar, enjoying the sushi, and taking a moment to appreciate the creativity all around you.

2 /5 Stinson Parks III: I had been wanting to try Atlantic Grill before hitting a show at Lincoln Center for a few months and finally made my way in before a show. The hostesses were accommodating and sat me right away but then I proceeded to wait almost 15 minutes before receiving any menus and a few minutes longer before my server finally checked in. Ended up getting the pre-theater pri fixe just in time before the cutoff and chose the subpar sushi roll, the penne that unfortunately came with a hair in it and vanilla ice cream dessert. The ambiance was Upper Eastside Manhattan with an older crowd you’d expect. Price points and ambiance were solid including a lively bar area where folks were also grabbing bites and drinks. Guess I should have “curbed my enthusiasm” a bit but I really had high hopes especially since it was moderately tough to get a resy locked in. Maybe just an off night….

5 /5 Noriko Lovasz: With the dim lighting and gorgeous crystal chandeliers, this place is elegant and lovely. We were seated at a table for 4, and so we were able to spread out and relax. Our server was friendly and provided us details on sides and desserts. Our lobster came out with different sauce options and was expertly prepared. And the bread basket was so pretty and also delicious. Bravo to present dessert with a birthday candle!

3 /5 Lissa Kline: We went for a pre-ballet brunch. The servers were so nice and initially super attentive. We got guacamole to share that was fresh and very good. Drinks were served quickly as well. The entrees however took nearly 90 minutes, despite us asking for updates. I think because the kitchen was backed up they stopped coming to our table. Oddly, tables sat after us got food sooner. When we got it, my food was cold and not appetizing. The bacon was cold and not crispy. Eggs were cold and dry. Bread tasted like the grill. Wouldn’t go back for brunch. It may be different for dinner and pre-show in the evening.

5 /5 Eui Sun Chung: This is my favorite restaurant near Lincoln Center. It’s always packed with stylish locals, mostly seniors, which adds to the charm and trust of the place. While dinner here is great, I had the pleasure of visiting for Sunday lunch with a special guest. As always, everything was delicious—from the fresh oysters and octopus carpaccio to the ravioli, paella, scallops, and dessert. The service was also impeccable. Once again, I was reminded that this is a restaurant that never disappoints, no matter when you visit.