The Brookside - Newfane (NY)

3 /5 Matt Thomas: First time being here after hearing very good things. Food wasn’t bad but it’s nothing to rave about. I ordered the beer batter fish fry; with coleslaw and Mac and cheese. While everything is homemade the slaw was good but the Mac was not cooked all the way and the noodles were still hard. Other people ordered the lobster stuffed haddock and shrimp, two cheeseburgers. We also started with fried cauliflower bites and pretzels for the appetizer. Again everything was not bad but it’s not a place that I would just say let’s go to the brookside. If you are in the area check it out it maybe your new favorite place.

5 /5 Sara Lang: This restaurant is absolutely amazing. The staff is wonderful. The food is great and I love the ambience. Everything is very clean and tidy. It’s hard to find a good restaurant nowadays but this place I would definitely recommend!! We met a sweet girl there as well. She was so friendly and had a great personality.. this girl named Jessica that works there and she was also noticeably very hard-working. If there were 10 stars available I would give it 10 stars.

4 /5 Justine Miller: Great food. I got chicken dinners and fries the first time I went, then got the chicken Caesar salad this time and it was the best one Ive ever had. I came back a few weeks later and we got the steak nachos as an appetizer along with the Mac n cheese bites. Both were delicious. The only problem we had was 45 minutes to get our main entrees and the service was not good. Everybody was nice tho, and the host tried hard as well. It was a Wednesday I believe.

5 /5 cynthia turner: They have a wonderful flight of soups! It is hard to find places that have homemade soups that are tasty! They offer about 6 different types of soups to pick from. They have a tasty baguette for an upcharge but well worth it! They are very friendly and drinks are very good as well! My husband loves the burgers too! My new favorite restaurant! I will be back!

4 /5 Sarah Marie: *Note: Review = updated from 7 yrs ago as facility is updated as well. Love what theyve done with this place. Had no idea they turned it into such a nice restaurant inside. Tons of menu options, friendly staff, food was good. Clean, nice atmosphere. Gluten free options. Nice little patio. Will return.