Decoy Restaurant - Rock Stream (NY)

5 /5 Michael Torres: We were lucky enough to get into town on a Friday night when the Decoy had their fish fry. Absolutely the best fish fry I have ever had. In fact, the filet, the chicken parm, and everything else we had was spectacular. Plus, Madison, our server, was happy, pleasant and a hunch of fun. Great service and phenomenal food. No need to look anywhere else!!

5 /5 Pam Kowulich: After visiting this little gem its no surprise they have been open 30+ years. Its a 45 minute drive for me but I wanted to give it a try before it started to get dark so early. I went up on a Saturday at 4, when they open. Very pleasant staff. I was dining solo and they showed me to a nice table with a view of the lake. I settled in, chatted with the nice waitress and ordered the prime rib. I got the larger size so I could take some home. Had a glass of my favorite Finger Lakes wine, MC² and enjoyed the pleasant surroundings. Dinner was delish, rare just like I ordered. Nice salad and vegetables completed the meal. Dont skip this place when youre in town. Get there early as it does fill up. Enjoy!

1 /5 Emily Schulz: This place has a very supper club vibe. We had some very bad service by our waitress, but it did seem to just be her and not the others. We waited about 10 min before anyone came to our table. We then waited for about 20 min to get our waters, which were then never refilled. We also never received the soup we ordered. We waited about an hour total for the microwaved unseasoned salmon and scampi with jarred pasta sauce. This place is way over priced. Overall, I would not recommend. The food was bland and the service was horrible. I’m not sure how it has the rating it currently has.

5 /5 Renea D: Definitely a decoy. Not always what’s on the outside. Very deceiving place. Glad we went to try it out. Amazing food, proportions of everything absolutely wont go hungry. Leftovers were taken home. I just don’t know if they have desserts. We were not offered any dessert menu. Recommend highly

5 /5 Jonathan Smith: Up here having a friends getaway and stopped in for dinner. All the staff was happy and very attentive. The food was very prompt. I ordered the filet mignon and it was the best I ever had. Every single food item I ordered or even tried was spectacular. I highly recommend this place. We’re in town for 2 more days and will be back tomorrow night for dinner again.