Giuseppes - Horseheads (NY)

2 /5 Matthew Kelly: This is what the $14 "Godfather Hoagie" looks like. I wonder how many other people saw a $14 Godfather on the menu and thought it was going to be amazing only to end up with this sad hunk of bread, barely sprinkled with the classic Godfather ingredients? The ingredients, by the way were fresh, Ill give them that. What I wont give them is another $14 for this sandwich. Stick with the pizza. The Margherita is incredibly delicious. I cant imagine anything on this menu with red sauce being bad either. Overall Giuseppes is a great place to eat and I will definitely continue to eat here, but if youre going for a sandwich there are much better options nearby. A note for the owners: Increase the meat portion and add cheese, lower the price to about $9, or just take it off the menu because you are stiffing your customers. I doubt you will ever get a repeat customer for this quality and price point. Also, how does this cost the same as a veal parm? Veal cutlets are $16/lb at Wegmans so that makes sense, but serving this atrocity with the same price as a veal parm misleads the customer into thinking their going to get a $14 sandwich. This is not a $14 sandwich.

5 /5 Dolly On the Go!: Just wow! The food! The service! We eat Italian often and this was exceptional. I had the bruschetta and lasagna. I highly recommend both.

4 /5 Amy Montondo: Food was good and service was also very good. I thought their prices were high for especially hoagies and salads. They should have a lunch menu with smaller portions for a cheaper alternative. But even the dinners were almost $30 each.

3 /5 THE6THBORO: My wife gives it a 7 , I say a 3 ? Kinda mid , Huge chunks of dry chicken on the buff chkn pizza ,crust was good , asked for the wings to be cooked well / crispy …they were not … deff not a go to spot.

5 /5 Amys The-Wise-One: TL;DR - Food is well worth it; Service is excellent; atmosphere is what it was. We were in town for a vacation, and the local hotel staff recommended them for dinner. So we went and was seated immediately, and served by Savannah immediately, with fresh sliced bread and plenty of time to make our choice. First time for dinner was Guisppies pizza (aka supreme) and its excellent, The crust was soft yet crisp, the toppings fresh, and plenty of good flavor. The second time for dinner, with Savannah again, the spouse got a Dinner sized grilled chicken salad and I had veal parmigana hogie. Once again, excellent dinner. And the cannolis? Wow. Best Ive had. Third time, he had a Cheesesteak special hoagie while I picked the stromboli. The boli was good hot or cold (leftovers the next days lunch) . Fourth time (earlier today) we split a pizza again. The only ding is for the last visit we hit between lunch and dinner time (before senior citizens dinner time) and only one young lady (IIRC Kristen) was busy working the phones, floor service, and back of store tasks. We understood and had no issues with it taking a little longer to get our check and depart. But for the food? And the amount of food? Worth it and more. Hate we never got to try the wings. When we return to the area for vacation, well give them a try.