Truffle Honey Eatery - Mayville (NY)

5 /5 Grace Camarata: This bar/restaurant was very good! The mocktail that I got was very yummy and so was the mushroom pizza. I think the mushroom pizza had way too much arugula though.

4 /5 J. Curious Company: I know I will be in the minority. Wonderful staff and an awesome waiter. The food. Well. Not great. I had a Caesar Salad with salmon. The Salad was not to my liking. WAY too many croutons. I was herding them to the side. Dressing was not memorable, neither was the salmon. Altogether undressed, and a bit dry. The one white anchovy filet was tasty. I would have liked more. The picture of the salad was def.not mine, but from another diner. Mind you Im very particular, but I have had Caesar salads at 4 star restaurants, and diners, and I always have a Caesar on my first trip to an eatery. Based on this salad, I would not return. I dined with two friends, one had spaghetti squash with a mushroom ragout, which was so over powered with garlic that she pushed it aside. (I tasted it, love garlic, and agreed. They had ordered an appetizer, which I didnt try, which she ate as her entre. Delicious wood oven fried pita bread and a dip. (I forget what.) Very tasty, especially the pita. I did have a very nice glass of Sauv. Blanc which dulled my pain. $60 including tip. Somewhere else maybe, but not in Chautauqua county. Maybe a steak or lobster of some other wonderful thing would have been better, but alas. Ill only return to exchange banter with our waiter, and maybe have a glass of wine.

5 /5 Remy W: We reserved Truffle Honey for our rehearsal dinner and welcome party the evening before our September 2025 wedding. We’ve really enjoyed this restaurant any time we’ve visited for dinner, and our event was beyond phenomenal! Our rehearsal dinner was held inside the restaurant, where staff organized a few long tables to accomodate about 50 people. We had a family style dinner and the food was amazing - they never miss! We had beautiful weather so our welcome party guests were able to enjoy both the restaurant and the beer garden - enjoting buffet style food and drinks from both bars! We could not have picked a better venue and would recommend Truffle Honey to anyone looking for a similar venue with great food!

2 /5 Jennifer Downey: I’m hesitant to share this review, because I usually don’t leave negative reviews on businesses. However, I do think our experience would prove useful to other families looking to eat here. Our family of 6 plus a 1 and a half year old made reservations over the phone. We were not discouraged from coming at all. We showed up and the staff were friendly, but the customers were anything but that. One lady at the bar made an openly rude comment about how the baby should not be there. We proceeded to push through the offense and still eat there but were placed in the way back corner in a separate room away from the anti-child “Karen” at a table that was in no way big enough for our group. My husband was sitting essentially between our table and another couple who were clearly on a date night. Given, there was an empty table, more than big enough for us, in the main room. We lasted 10 minutes and realized no one was even going to have room to cut their steaks. We requested our appetizers be put in a carry out box, paid, and left. We’ve never been so embarrassed. After our request, we were offered the table in the main room but “Karen” was still seated there and we were emotionally over feeling out of place. Our family has eaten at fancier steakhouses in Cleveland and never been so uncomfortable. Sadly, the restaurant probably missed out on a 300-400 dollar party due to the rudeness of one customer and poor planning when it came to table spacing/hospitality. Such a shame!

5 /5 Kimberly Dugan: Absolutely outstanding food. Everything was fresh and came out rather quickly. We ordered the warm asiago bread, salmon and steak. We sat at the bar, and although the bartender was rather busy she was still really attentive and friendly to us. The atmosphere was very cute. The one thing I would say is to make a reservation because seating is limited!