Top 12 Budget-Friendly Restaurants Near You in Mayville, NY

Laura Tofil Amazing addition to the area!!! One of the best lattes i’ve had and my friends said the same. All of our food was phenomenal. Staff and service was so welcoming and had overall great hospitality. The views and ambiance are a bonus. The chef Travis came and checked on us as well. We will be back again & again!

Susan Baranoff What a sweet place to stumble into on a late Sunday afternoon. We were looking for "2nd meal" and this was the perfect menu. Sat on the covered patio and really enjoyed being outdoors but out of the sun as well. The meatball sub is excellent as is the Nicks sausage sub. Subs were served with bagged chips and a pickle spear. 12" subs are enough for two meals for us! The Bloody Mary was the least successful ordered item reported as being "impressively bad" - no celery salt, no Worcestershire sauce, no horseradish, not even salt, and maybe made with Clamato juice? just not good. That said, the prosecco was lovely and the Tiramisu delicious. Our server was friendly and helpful. Family owned restaurant. If we lived in the area wed make it there every few weeks.

Beth Smialek Our waitress Julie was the best from start to finish. Food was good. Love the seasonal decor and oil lamps on the table.

Timothy Bowen Delicious, affordable, made fresh.

Andy Statler Room was very nice, full bathroom with shower and separate smaller bathroom with sink and toilet. Beds were very comfortable. Breakfast was basic but had a great selection of cereals, Jimmy Dean breakfast sandwiches, breads and milk.

Mark Swanger Great atmosphere friendly people ,great bartender, food was delicious. Special was flounder stuffed with crab meat. VERY GOOD FOOD .

GregYaz Great meals at a wonderfully welcoming price. Wings and pizza are excellent. Staff is very friendly and made us feel appreciated as guests. Just had that feel they they really wanted us to be happy and comfortable. Meal portions are large, especially given the reasonable prices.

Sheri Kamikow We made a reservation and we were able to get in at the time we asked for. Our server Alice was pretty fantastic. She cleared the table before we got there. She had to wash the table and then she seated us and had to deal with a ton of other people outside and she did it efficiently and she was super friendly. The food was good. My only complaint is it seemed like the kitchen had a hard Managing the Orders. It took over 60 minutes to get our food, but it was worth the weight. They should have three more people named Alice working in their Restaurant she was the best part of the experience!

Renee Kaznowski I couldnt not write a review, this place was so stellar. Each dish, from main entree, to each side dish, to the drinks, was an orchestra of flavors! The salmon, flounder and hamburger meat were perfectly cooked. The seasoning of each entree and dish was divine. Every worker we encountered was very pleasant, especially our engaging waiter Jonathan. Even the smoothies and Irish coffee were delicious. We were only visiting, but look forward to visiting when we are in the area again!

Grace Camarata This bar/restaurant was very good! The mocktail that I got was very yummy and so was the mushroom pizza. I think the mushroom pizza had way too much arugula though.

Matt Jones Relatively new restaurant in Mayville. Went on a whim with the wife and we loved it! It was packed for a Thursday night, but the staff had us at a table immediately. With 5 minutes, we had drinks ordered and some chips with salsa. The salsa was quite nice, too. I got a burrito diabla and my wife got a fajita bowl. I doubt we waited more than 10 minutes before the food was served. Both of us really liked our meals and packed some away for lunch the next day. Something important to know is that they are still waiting for their liquor license, so no cocktails or beer...yet. Also, parking is available. If they are busy, you may have to walk a few minutes to get to the restaurant. Finally, the service was awesome. We were helped by no less than 5 staff, which made the whole experience that much better. All in all, definitely come give Pueblo Real a try!

Ross Barr We had chicken wings & pizza logs, my husband loved the wings… he got a spicy bourbon and said it was outstanding. Pizza logs were good. Fast service! A good variety of food. We had their food at Busti Apple Festival! I hope they return each year