new-york Date: 09-18-2025

Top 14 Rated Jeweler in Rochester, NY (part 2)

Jewelry StoresAddress
1The Gem Lab - Jewelry & Custom Design4098 W Henrietta Rd, Rochester, NY 14623
2Estate & Fine Jewelry by Harry Krikorian3025 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618
3Charisma Jewelers2330 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14626
4Borinquen Jewelry980 N Clinton Ave, Rochester, NY 14621
5Jewelry and Coin Exchange1964 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14626
6Roc Gold and Diamond224 Greece Ridge Center Dr, Rochester, NY 14626
7High Def Jewelry2831 W Henrietta Rd, Rochester, NY 14623
8Manns Jewelers2945 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618
9All Things Antiques And Collectibles2788 Dewey Ave, Rochester, NY 14616
10Stefan Otter Jewelers2314 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618
11Northfield Designer Goldsmiths700 Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14607
12Gajmer Jewellers3047 W Henrietta Rd, Rochester, NY 14623
13Jeweld Permanent Jewelry2326 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618
14Aarons Alley662 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14607

1.The Gem Lab - Jewelry & Custom Design

Address: 4098 W Henrietta Rd, Rochester, NY 14623

(424) user ratings total:

A J David is fabulous and made my entire experience amazing. He took as much time as I needed to work through selling some jewelry as that can be an emotional event. After, he quickly came up with some beautiful designs to use the stones that remained. I absolutely love the rings he designed for me. Jewelry that had been stuffed away, broken or too small has now been transformed. Every day I have beauty and wonderful memories glimmering up at me. I am so thankful for Davids patience and skill. I am thrilled to put these on in the morning. (The picture doesnt really do them justice.) So go and see for yourself. You will walk out grinning.
5 /5

2.Estate & Fine Jewelry by Harry Krikorian

Address: 3025 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618

(42) user ratings total:

Angela Campbell This place is amazing. They have some unusual pieces, and I had the pleasure of meeting Harry and Stephanie. They are great people. Harry gives great prices, goes above and beyond for his customers, and has top-tier customer service. ❤️
5 /5

3.Charisma Jewelers

Address: 2330 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14626

(405) user ratings total:

JT Wegman I can’t thank charisma and a team there they did an absolute amazing job as I was traveling for two months planning a wedding making engagement rings and necklaces. The experience went off absolutely amazing. Everything was perfect. Timing delivery response time five stars is not enough.
5 /5

4.Borinquen Jewelry

Address: 980 N Clinton Ave, Rochester, NY 14621

(40) user ratings total:

Calvin Parnell They buy and sell gold and white gold only
5 /5

5.Jewelry and Coin Exchange

Address: 1964 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14626

(40) user ratings total:

Andre Martinez I been coming here since I was 13 years old and let me tell you the staff is amazing! They always treated me like family and their prices are unmatched! Hands down best prices around period! I will always be there customer! Thank you Jewery and coin exchange!
5 /5

6.Roc Gold and Diamond

Address: 224 Greece Ridge Center Dr, Rochester, NY 14626

(4) user ratings total:

Mr. Toole I get all my jewelry from my guy at Roc Gold & Diamond. If he doesn’t have what you want physically in store he can for sure get it, and at a great price. I’ve been buying pieces from him for the past 6+ years. 10/10 would recommend!!!
5 /5

7.High Def Jewelry

Address: 2831 W Henrietta Rd, Rochester, NY 14623

(4) user ratings total:

Miguel Rodriguez Amazing people always taken care of me like family!! I wouldnt take business anywhere else!! If you are shopping elsewhere stop now go see them they will treat you like FAMILY!!
5 /5

8.Manns Jewelers

Address: 2945 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618

(362) user ratings total:

Elizabeth Deery When we initially began the process of looking for rings, I was interested in checking out Manns Jewelers. Nevertheless, due to scheduling they ended up being the 7th jeweler we visited - and lucky number 7 it was! From the beginning our experience was different - it was personable, not pushy and Bonnie spent more than an hour with us the first day, even though we had told her we werent going to purchase that day. We viewed and I tried on dozens of rings, and in the end made the decision to customize an already beautiful Gabriel & Co. piece - though we did not purchase that day we were back just a few days later to finalize. Throughout the process Bonnie sought to educate us on what we were purchasing and to make us clients, not simply another number in and out - both of which are more than I can say for a few other places we visited. We definitely recommend Manns Jewelers - we went in for a purchase but came out with a jeweler and we look forward to working with them in the future!
5 /5

9.All Things Antiques And Collectibles

Address: 2788 Dewey Ave, Rochester, NY 14616

(35) user ratings total:

AR M Interesting mix of things. Looked like 2/3 of it didnt have a price, including literally everything I was interested in. Nobody said anything the whole time we were in there. Store isnt really big enough to have more than like 2 people in it at once. Also it REEKED of Marijuana. If youre going to run a store that small maybe only smoke after the store is closed for the day. The stuff that actually did have prices were comparable to other antique stores, though.
3 /5

10.Stefan Otter Jewelers

Address: 2314 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618

images Stefan Otter Jewelers

(33) user ratings total:

Andrea Taylor Several years after my husband passed away, I was unsure what to do with my diamond engagement ring. Mariela and Stefan created a beautiful pendant using my diamond and the gold from my late husbands wedding ring. I will cherish this piece forever.
5 /5

11.Northfield Designer Goldsmiths

Address: 700 Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14607

(32) user ratings total:

Dennis Newberry Gudmund has been my go to jeweller for these past 17 years. It started with my engagement ring for my fiance as well as my beautiful wedding band. Over the years Gudmund has collaborated with me on one of a kind designs for me and for my wife. Some great memories with jewelry that will become heirlooms for the generations.
5 /5

12.Gajmer Jewellers

Address: 3047 W Henrietta Rd, Rochester, NY 14623

(31) user ratings total:

Sujan Senchury New design and best service in town
5 /5

13.Jeweld Permanent Jewelry

Address: 2326 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618

(3) user ratings total:

Teresa Berley I’ve been to Jeweld several times and gotten 3 different pieces of jewelry. I love the way Ashlee sets up so everything is easy to see with a fantastic selection. She is very pleasant and professional and it was so quick. I totally recommend!!! I will be going again!!
5 /5

14.Aarons Alley

Address: 662 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14607

(280) user ratings total:

Madison Callahan absolutely adore this place! i have been wanting these headbands from there for the longest that they stopped selling. I also moved down to florida and they were kind of enough to find them and order them for me ANNNND ship them to me all the way down in florida. and they gave me some stones and stickers in the package
5 /5