new-york Date: 09-18-2025

Best 13 Jewelry Stores Near You Buffalo, NY

Jewelry StoresAddress
1Ross & Company Jewelers3510 McKinley Pkwy, Buffalo, NY 14219
2Vania & David779 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
3Colosseum Jewelry1 Galleria Dr, Buffalo, NY 14225
4SARA JEWELRY171 Walden Ave store #7, Buffalo, NY 14211
5Express Jewelers1 Walden Galleria, Buffalo, NY 14225
6CowPok Piercing + Tattoo Gallery111 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14201
7Bomi Jewelers4574 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14226
8Korona Jewelry1588 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
9Pauls Jewelry Designs12 N Ellicott Creek Rd, Buffalo, NY 14228
10AthosPvtLtd88 Hartwell Rd, Buffalo, NY 14216
11Aurum Jewelers487 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
12Main Jewelers440 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14202
13Bailey Jewelry3124 Bailey Ave, Buffalo, NY 14215

1.Ross & Company Jewelers

Address: 3510 McKinley Pkwy, Buffalo, NY 14219

images Ross & Company Jewelers

(98) user ratings total:

Suzanne McKellar My twin 8 year old grandsons bought watches at a thrift store, but the batteries were dead. I stopped in to Ross Jewelers to get batteries. The owner was so kind, changed the battery in the first watch and kindly explained why the missing "diamonds" couldnt be replaced (lol). Apparently the second watch was broken and a new battery wouldnt help. He asked my grandson to give him his wrist and he put a very nice looking watch (not new) on his wrist and left him beaming!! Then he refused payment!! He wouldnt let me pay for the battery or the watch!! This was such a generous act of kindness, I just want everyone know how he lit up the world for these little boys!!
5 /5

2.Vania & David

Address: 779 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222

images Vania & David

(9) user ratings total:

Alexander Juda I absolutely loved my ring— Vania and David were so kind and generous and insistent on me getting the most incredible ring possible. She sat me down and showed me every single gem and material to make the ring with— she even measured every finger of mine that didn’t have a ring on it just in case I changed my mind. She was very patient and excited to help me create my own custom ring! It was a phenomenal experience- I recommend Vania and David to every single ring-wearer. I would, definitely, do this again.
5 /5

3.Colosseum Jewelry

Address: 1 Galleria Dr, Buffalo, NY 14225

(875) user ratings total:

Call me Prettyinpink I walked in and walked out with some pressure!! Very professional, the women that took care of me made sure I got what I want at a great price. The manager was very accommodating as well. Ill be back for a custom piece!!
5 /5

4.SARA JEWELRY

Address: 171 Walden Ave store #7, Buffalo, NY 14211

(8) user ratings total:

Humaira Hasan my mom is very happy with the bangles she bought from this store, she says the quality is excellent and the prices are very fair. the owners are friendly too, so we recommend taking a look!
5 /5

5.Express Jewelers

Address: 1 Walden Galleria, Buffalo, NY 14225

(72) user ratings total:

Mary Rapisardi My friend bought a chain from here for my son as a Christmas gift. He got it today, my son is 12 and loves this chain and charm. I personally havent been in there but will be in the future. Really nice quality.
5 /5

6.CowPok Piercing + Tattoo Gallery

Address: 111 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14201

(715) user ratings total:

Jordan Speed Made an appointment on a whim for piercings. The website/appointment booking was super easy and user friendly. Got to the shop and it was extremely clean and the staff were so knowledgeable, helpful and welcoming! Got pierced by Trevor and he was amazing! Kept us super calm and relaxed but also was just a super cool human to be around. Will definitely recommend to everyone and be going back for more piercings!
5 /5

7.Bomi Jewelers

Address: 4574 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14226

(68) user ratings total:

Marisa Lewis Every experience at Bomi’s Jewelers has been incredible customer service! Brandon D. has helped me with my engagement ring and wedding bands. He is very knowledgeable and kind. I will always be coming back at Bomi’s with my jewelry needs!
5 /5

8.Korona Jewelry

Address: 1588 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216

(60) user ratings total:

jonathan thomson This is the place to get a custom engagement ring in Buffalo. Its family run and everyone was extremely helpful in designing a custom ring in CAD that my now wife loves. They have a wide selection and can order anything.
5 /5

9.Pauls Jewelry Designs

Address: 12 N Ellicott Creek Rd, Buffalo, NY 14228

(581) user ratings total:

michael I brought some broken family jewelry in to see if Paul could use to create a ring for my husband. He immediately drew up a rough sketch of his idea and had a rendering over to me in less than a day. His idea to inlay my broken rings into a new ring was genius and it couldn’t have turned out better. The turn around time wasn’t very long and the ring when done was more beautiful and perfect than I could have ever expected. This is the second custom ring I’ve had Paul Custom Jewelry create and they have not disappointed! Highly recommend!
5 /5

10.AthosPvtLtd

Address: 88 Hartwell Rd, Buffalo, NY 14216

(5) user ratings total:

Ahmed Mahbub Absolutely love their jewelry! I ordered a few pairs of earrings and they’re even more beautiful in person. The quality is great, prices are affordable, and the styles go with everything from casual to dressy. Shipping was quick too. Definitely recommend checking out their collection if you’re looking for something stylish and well made.
5 /5

11.Aurum Jewelers

Address: 487 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222

(497) user ratings total:

Bauble Love This is my second visit with Aurem Jewelers (each trip with multiple pieces) and I have nothing but praise for this local, longtime neighborhood jeweler. The main service this time around was my engagement ring upgrade. It had become too large after weight loss and Aurem’s bench did a superb job re-sizing it, keeping the engraving and hallmarks intact, and sizing it down without sacrificing the band’s integrity or the shape of the ring. I’m so pleased with their service, communication, and quick turnaround. Paul, Billy, and Vanya are absolute pleasures to work with. I’m looking forward to creating a custom piece with them in the future. ~ Marie Z.
5 /5

12.Main Jewelers

Address: 440 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14202

(48) user ratings total:

Pedro Valentin Very respectful people who do business in that jewelry.
1 /5

13.Bailey Jewelry

Address: 3124 Bailey Ave, Buffalo, NY 14215

(46) user ratings total:

J J I will never support them again I’ve always supported them since their old location. Previously they’ve given my other customer orders and me being a good person returnee the jewelry back to them. They messed up a lot. Still forgave them and continued to get jewelry from them. I recently purchased some diamond earrings with a screw back. I advised him that the screw back wasn’t working he said there’s nothing he can do. I only had the earrings for a couple weeks. Bottom line I wore the earrings since the screw back wasn’t working I lost one of the earrings. I will never go back to them again! I’ve been going to them for years! Also to add I did call him in regards to my earring I still have and asked him to fix the back and he said NO! He is a liar!
1 /5