Jerry and The Mermaid - Riverhead (NY)

5 /5 Andrea Alvarez: We had the pleasure of having Whitney as our server and by far the best customer service Ive ever had in a restaurant. The food was delicious and this place is very cute. I would 100 percent come back but I live in Florida. Hopefully next time I come up I can come back!

5 /5 Nicole Guarasci: We booked Jerry and The Mermaid for our rehearsal dinner and it was the best night ever! Jerry and his team were so accommodating, helpful and such a good time. Most importantly the food was incredible! All our guests were raving all wedding weekend (and still to this day asking to go back)! The service was exceptional. Everyone had a new drink right as they finished their last one & everyone was so kind! I was also a crazy bride who provided an outline for the decor thinking our family would set up when they arrived but Jerry’s team did it all and perfectly going above and beyond. It was so amazing working with Jerry and you should definitely book your next private event here! We can’t wait to visit again soon!

5 /5 Brigette Staack: I love seafood, but Im from Nebraska, which is a double landlocked state. The fish here is the most delicious thing Ive ever tasted. Our waitress was very pleasant and helped me choose which meal to order. She was also attentive to our needs. My friend had the chicken sandwich and also enjoyed it. If I ever make it back to this area, I will definitely eat here again.

5 /5 mich1127: I’ve been coming to Jerry’s for over 15 years, and it’s still just as amazing as ever. The food remains top-notch, and it’s great to see Jerry’s son carrying on the tradition with the same high standards. Everything here is fresh, flavorful, and consistently well-prepared. The seafood is always incredibly fresh and tastes fantastic. The chicken wings are a must-try—they’re a classic appetizer and one of my all-time favorites. I also highly recommend the artichoke hearts, another standout appetizer. Between my family and me, we’ve tried just about everything on the menu, and there isn’t a single thing we’d complain about. The quality is always there. All the seafood dishes are fantastic! The steak is excellent, and the steak sandwich is one of the best around. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or a relaxed meal, Jerry’s is definitely worth a visit. And the bonus? A lovely little view of the water and boats that adds to the charm. You won’t be disappointed!

5 /5 Ashley V: First, I had to look up how to write a review because Ive never left one anywhere. The service and food was unmatched. Im from the Midwest and had never had a lobster roll and wanted to try both. The chef prepared a small amount of the cold roll so I could also try it. Both were phenomenal. If you dont try the peanut butter pie you will without a doubt regret it. The server brought so much joy after an emotionally filled trip. They didnt know but we had just taken the ferry back from going to a memorial golf tournament from our best friend that passed away from our squadron. Go for the lobster, stay for the service, have pie, leave happy. Thanks for the delicious food and mutch needed laughter.