Oswego Sub Shop - Oswego (NY)

3 /5 Shelley Steele: Food amazing, quality amazing, I don’t mind the prices! Best wings in town! But why skimp so much on the meat? I have to order double meat to get a normal portion. Last night I got the pulled pork sandwich it was all sauce and so little meat it was a joke.

3 /5 Lord Paul bush: Honestly great food if you get it in person and eat there but if you order it for delivery it will be an absolute soupy mess. Ive ordered delivery numerous times and no matter what I order it comes feeling like it was dumped in a pool of water

2 /5 Amanda Brady: Hit Or miss, over all meh, not something to write home about. Al Roker seems to like the place a lot.The kids meals however are adorable! My sub (adult, not kids) one of the last times we went as we were in the area was all lettuce and only two halves of a tomato slice so I was a bit bummed. Cooked/hot subs tend to be overcooked, so beware. Also, I tried. Cookie, wont again, way to much butter for me, but I know people like that. Updated review as I took photos when I was in last and we waited like 25 min for subs, it was busy, bit not like packed, just consistent. The kid was literally leaning on the sub wrappers, and when I mention this I got attitude. And the subs we got the last time were very messy. Will deff not go back after this trip, and we usually go when we are up all summer long, but not after this one.

1 /5 Sumosweat: Definitely not the worst place I’ve been to, but DEFINITELY far from the best. I paid $34 for a foot long ham and cheese sub, 5 chicken tenders, & fries. The man who took my order wasn’t rude, I don’t know if he was having a bad day or what but he said a total of four words. He didn’t respond when I asked how he was doing, he didn’t respond after I said thank you, and he didn’t confirm my order with me. He stayed silent and wrote my order down, which isn’t totally bad but it didn’t make me feel welcome by any means. The ham and cheese sub was pretty decent, id give it a 6/10 compared to other sub shops I’ve been to. But it was by far the most expensive. The chicken tenders? By far the worst I’ve ever had. It tasted like chicken but with the consistency of jello. The fries were pretty amazing I won’t lie, super crispy and seasoned very well. But even at half the price, I still don’t think I’d go back.

5 /5 Catie Michelle: I can honestly say that Oswego Sub Shop has never let me down. Their subs are consistently great—fresh ingredients, perfectly made, and always exactly how I order. The flavors are spot-on every time, which keeps me coming back. The staff is super friendly and welcoming, making the experience even better. Its my go-to spot whenever I need a satisfying sub, and I genuinely love supporting this local business. Highly recommend!